Background and Objective: The aim of this study was to compare the efficacy and reliability of holmium (Ho:YAG) laser lithotripsy (HLL) and pneumatic lithotripsy (PL) in percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) in the treatment of patients with Grade IV kidney stones based on Guy’s Stone Score. Study Design/Materials and Methods: This retrospective study included 103 patients with Grade IV kidney stones out of 440 patients who underwent PCNL through HLL and PL in Second Affiliated Hospital of Shantou University Medical College, China, from January 2016 to December 2018. We analyzed preoperative, intraoperative, and postoperative variables of the patients to evaluate the efficacy and reliability of PCNL procedures. Results: Patients were categorized as Grade I, II, III, and IV, and the patients of each grade were 85 (19.32%), 39 (8.86%), 213 (48.41%), and 103 (23.41%), respectively. In Grade IV, the total operative time (min) for the PL and HLL groups was 137.7 ± 47.79 and 134.27 ± 53.38, respectively (p = 0.744). The variation in laboratory examination values including ΔHGB (g/L), ΔHCT, ΔPCT, and ΔCr (μmol/L) for PL and HLL groups was 19 ± 11.23/12 ± 15.42 (p = 0.012), 0.057 ± 0.034/0.038 ± 0.045 (0.009), 0.027 ± 0.034/0.026 ± 0.034 (0.702), and 3.07 ± 17.4/20.54 ± 65.93 (0.692), respectively. The postoperative hospitalization day was 8.94 ± 4.2 and 7.73 ± 2.75 (p = 0.015), respectively. As for the stone-free rate (SFR), the SFRs for PL and HLL were 48.15% (n = 39/81) and 59.09% (n = 13/22) (p = 0.363), respectively. Conclusions: HLL showed a comparable advantage of not only decreased postoperative hemoglobin and hematocrit but also fewer postoperative hospitalization days. Based on the results of our retrospective study, for those Grade IV kidney stone patients who have a risk of bleeding before PCNL operation, HLL can be a considerable treatment option. Besides, in consideration of reducing human care cost, HLL which showed fewer hospitalization days, would be more welcome by patients.

1.
Scales
CD
,
Smith
AC
,
Hanley
JM
,
Saigal
CS
.
Prevalence of kidney stones in the United States
.
Eur Urol
.
2012 Jul
;
62
(
1
):
160
5
.
2.
Zeng
G
,
Mai
Z
,
Xia
S
,
Wang
Z
,
Zhang
K
,
Wang
L
, et al.
Prevalence of kidney stones in China: an ultrasonography based cross-sectional study
.
BJU Int
.
2017 Jul
;
120
(
1
):
109
16
.
3.
Ordon
M
,
Urbach
D
,
Mamdani
M
,
Saskin
R
,
Honey
RJDA
,
Pace
KT
.
The surgical management of kidney stone disease: a population based time series analysis
.
J Urol
.
2014 Nov
;
192
(
5
):
1450
6
.
4.
Matlaga
BR
;
American Board of Urology
.
Contemporary surgical management of upper urinary tract calculi
.
J Urol
.
2009 May
;
181
(
5
):
2152
6
.
5.
Preminger
GM
,
Assimos
DG
,
Lingeman
JE
,
Nakada
SY
,
Pearle
MS
,
Wolf
JS
.
Chapter 1: AUA guideline on management of staghorn calculi: diagnosis and treatment recommendations
.
J Urol
.
2005 Jun
;
173
(
6
):
1991
2000
.
6.
Assimos
D
,
Krambeck
A
,
Miller
NL
,
Monga
M
,
Murad
MH
,
Nelson
CP
, et al.
Surgical management of stones: American urological association/endourological society guideline, part I
.
J Urol
.
2016
;
196
(
4
):
1153
60
.
7.
Demir
A
,
Karadag
MA
,
Cecen
K
,
Uslu
M
,
Arslan
OE
.
Pneumatic versus laser ureteroscopic lithotripsy: a comparison of initial outcomes and cost
.
Int Urol Nephrol
.
2014 Nov
;
46
(
11
):
2087
93
.
8.
Ghani
KR
,
Andonian
S
,
Bultitude
M
,
Desai
M
,
Giusti
G
,
Okhunov
Z
, et al.
Percutaneous nephrolithotomy: update, trends, and future directions
.
Eur Urol
.
2016 Aug
;
70
(
2
):
382
96
.
9.
Michel
MS
,
Trojan
L
,
Rassweiler
JJ
.
Complications in percutaneous nephrolithotomy
.
Eur Urol
.
2007
;
51
(
4
):
899
906
.
10.
Thomas
K
,
Smith
NC
,
Hegarty
N
,
Glass
JM
.
The guy’s stone score: grading the complexity of percutaneous nephrolithotomy procedures
.
Urology
.
2011 Aug
;
78
(
2
):
277
81
.
11.
Smith
A
,
Averch
TD
,
Shahrour
K
,
Opondo
D
,
Daels
FPJ
,
Labate
G
, et al.
A nephrolithometric nomogram to predict treatment success of percutaneous nephrolithotomy
.
J Urol
.
2013
;
190
(
1
):
149
56
.
12.
Okhunov
Z
,
Friedlander
JI
,
George
AK
,
Duty
BD
,
Moreira
DM
,
Srinivasan
AK
, et al.
S.T.O.N.E. nephrolithometry: novel surgical classification system for kidney calculi
.
Urology
.
2013
;
81
(
6
):
1154
60
.
13.
Sfoungaristos
S
,
Gofrit
ON
,
Pode
D
,
Landau
EH
,
Duvdevani
M
.
Percutaneous nephrolithotomy for staghorn stones: which nomogram can better predict postoperative outcomes?
World J Urol
.
2016
;
34
(
8
):
1163
8
.
14.
Akcay
M
,
Tosun
M
,
Gevher
F
,
Kalkan
S
,
Ersoz
C
,
Kayali
Y
, et al.
Comparison of scoring systems in predicting success of percutaneous nephrolithotomy
.
Balkan Med J
.
2019 Jan 1
;
36
(
1
):
32
6
.
15.
Ercil
H
,
Altunkol
A
,
Alma
E
,
Goren
MR
,
Sener
NC
,
Kuyucu
F
, et al.
Comparison of Ho:Yag laser and pneumatic lithotripsy combined with transurethral prostatectomy in high burden bladder stones with benign prostatic hyperplasia
.
Asian J Surg
.
2016 Oct
;
39
(
4
):
238
42
.
16.
Tiselius
HG
,
Andersson
A
.
Stone burden in an average Swedish population of stone formers requiring active stone removal: how can the stone size be estimated in the clinical routine?
Eur Urol
.
2003
;
43
(
3
):
275
81
.
17.
Singh
AK
,
Shukla
PK
,
Khan
SW
,
Rathee
VS
,
Dwivedi
US
,
Trivedi
S
.
Using the modified Clavien grading system to classify complications of percutaneous nephrolithotomy
.
Curr Urol
.
2018 Feb
;
11
(
2
):
79
84
.
18.
Wright
A
,
Rukin
N
,
Smith
D
,
De la Rosette
J
,
Somani
BK
.
“Mini, ultra, micro”: nomenclature and cost of these new minimally invasive percutaneous nephrolithotomy (PCNL) techniques
.
Ther Adv Urol
.
2016
;
8
(
2
):
142
6
.
19.
Diri
A
,
Diri
B
.
Management of staghorn renal stones
.
Ren Fail
.
2018 Nov
;
40
(
1
):
357
62
.
20.
Gettman
MT
,
Segura
JW
.
Struvite stones: diagnosis and current treatment concepts
.
J Endourol
.
1999
;
13
(
9
):
653
8
.
21.
Desai
M
,
De Lisa
A
,
Turna
B
,
Rioja
J
,
Walfridsson
H
,
D'Addessi
A
, et al.
The clinical research office of the endourological society percutaneous nephrolithotomy global study: staghorn versus nonstaghorn stones
.
J Endourol
.
2011 Aug
;
25
(
8
):
1263
8
.
22.
Akman
T
,
Binbay
M
,
Kezer
C
,
Yuruk
E
,
Tekinarslan
E
,
Ozgor
F
, et al.
Factors affecting kidney function and stone recurrence rate after percutaneous nephrolithotomy for staghorn calculi: outcomes of a long-term followup
.
J Urol
.
2012 May
;
187
(
5
):
1656
61
.
23.
Knoll
T
,
Daels
F
,
Desai
J
,
Hoznek
A
,
Knudsen
B
,
Montanari
E
, et al.
Percutaneous nephrolithotomy: technique
.
World J Urol
.
2017 Sep
;
35
(
9
):
1361
8
.
24.
Liu
C
,
Zhou
H
,
Jia
W
,
Hu
H
,
Zhang
H
,
Li
L
.
The efficacy of percutaneous nephrolithotomy using pneumatic lithotripsy vs. the holmium laser: a randomized study
.
Indian J Surg
.
2017 Aug
;
79
(
4
):
294
8
.
25.
Sarkissian
C
,
Cui
Y
,
Mohsenian
K
,
Watts
K
,
Gao
T
,
Tarplin
S
, et al.
Tissue damage from ultrasonic, pneumatic, and combination lithotripsy
.
J Endourol
.
2015 Feb
;
29
(
2
):
162
70
.
26.
Chen
S
,
Zhou
L
,
Wei
T
,
Luo
D
,
Jin
T
,
Li
H
, et al.
Comparison of holmium: Yag laser and pneumatic lithotripsy in the treatment of ureteral stones: an update meta-analysis
.
Urol Int
.
2017
;
98
(
2
):
125
33
.
27.
Atar
M
,
Bodakci
MN
,
Sancaktutar
AA
,
Penbegul
N
,
Soylemez
H
,
Bozkurt
Y
, et al.
Comparison of pneumatic and laser lithotripsy in the treatment of pediatric ureteral stones
.
J Pediatr Urol
.
2013 Jun
;
9
(
3
):
308
12
.
28.
Kessaris
DN
,
Bellman
GC
,
Pardalidis
NP
,
Smith
AG
.
Management of hemorrhage after percutaneous renal surgery
.
J Urol
.
1995
;
153
:
604
8
.
29.
Stammen
LA
,
Stalmeijer
RE
,
Paternotte
E
,
Oudkerk Pool
A
,
Driessen
EW
,
Scheele
F
, et al.
Training physicians to provide high-value, cost-conscious care: a systematic review
.
JAMA
.
2015 Dec 08
;
314
(
22
):
2384
400
.
30.
El-Nahas
AR
,
Elshal
AM
,
El-Tabey
NA
,
El-Assmy
AM
,
Shokeir
AA
.
Percutaneous nephrolithotomy for staghorn stones: a randomised trial comparing high-power holmium laser versus ultrasonic lithotripsy
.
BJU Int
.
2016 Aug
;
118
(
2
):
307
12
.
31.
Wiener
SV
,
Deters
LA
, Pais VM
.
Effect of stone composition on operative time during ureteroscopic holmium:yttrium-aluminum-garnet laser lithotripsy with active fragment retrieval
.
Urology
.
2012
;
80
(
4
):
790
4
.
32.
Kadihasanoglu
M
,
Yucetas
U
,
Çulha
MG
,
Erkan
E
,
Toktas
MG
.
Effect of stone composition on the outcomes of semi-rigid ureteroscopy using holmium:yttrium-aluminum-garnet laser or pneumatic lithotripsy
.
J Coll Phys Surg Pakistan
.
2017
;
27
(
4
):
227
31
.
Copyright / Drug Dosage / Disclaimer
Copyright: All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be translated into other languages, reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, microcopying, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Drug Dosage: The authors and the publisher have exerted every effort to ensure that drug selection and dosage set forth in this text are in accord with current recommendations and practice at the time of publication. However, in view of ongoing research, changes in government regulations, and the constant flow of information relating to drug therapy and drug reactions, the reader is urged to check the package insert for each drug for any changes in indications and dosage and for added warnings and precautions. This is particularly important when the recommended agent is a new and/or infrequently employed drug.
Disclaimer: The statements, opinions and data contained in this publication are solely those of the individual authors and contributors and not of the publishers and the editor(s). The appearance of advertisements or/and product references in the publication is not a warranty, endorsement, or approval of the products or services advertised or of their effectiveness, quality or safety. The publisher and the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to persons or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content or advertisements.
You do not currently have access to this content.