Purpose: Descriptive psychopathology (DP) is the language of psychiatry and is dedicated to the description of mental symptoms. Despite its core importance, a systematic review identified a series of shortcomings in its training. This Delphi study seeks to provide guidance for better didactic and clinical training in DP. Method: The authors used the Delphi method in order to gather, pool, and optimize the knowledgeable opinion of a highly qualified panel of international experts on how to improve DP training. A preliminary phase with open-ended questions was the basis to elaborate a Delphi questionnaire consisting of 14 questions on didactic and clinical training, which was then used in two successive Delphi rounds. Twenty-nine international experts in DP participated throughout the study. Results: A series of hierarchical lists on how to improve DP training were elaborated. Regarding didactic training, the experts valued the contents and educational methods, as well as recommended authors and texts. Regarding clinical training, the experts valued educational methods, desirable characteristics in clinical supervisors, how to improve the supervisors’ expertise, useful aspects and facilitating questions for direct supervision, and the suitability of including other evaluators besides the supervisor. In the final survey, 94% of the experts considered that the Delphi method had been effective to obtain and improve their opinions. Conclusions: Insufficient direct supervision in live interviews was considered the most important problem. A series of general measures were proposed to improve DP training: (i) adapting DP training throughout residency, with introductory and advanced levels; (ii) making DP training compulsory in psychiatry curricula; (iii) assessing residents’ DP knowledge and clinical use; and (iv) training the trainers/supervisors in both content (DP) and form (how to train/supervise residents). Within didactic training, epistemology of DP and contemporary and classic authors/texts were the highest rated contents, while supervised discussions based on cases, videos, or readings were the highest rated methods. Within clinical training, 8 aspects of DP that could guide the supervisor were highly rated: mental state examination, dialogue, empathy and understanding, attitude/willingness, knowledge-practice bridge, mental symptom formation, implications for decision-making, and the written report of the encounter.

1.
Berrios
GE
.
History and epistemology of psychopathology
. In:
Kendler
KS
,
Parnas
J
, editors.
Philosophical issues in psychiatry III. The nature and sources of historical change
.
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
;
2015
. p.
30
50
.
2.
Berrios
GE
,
Marková
IS
.
Toward a new epistemology of psychiatry
. In:
Kirmayer
LJ
,
Lemelson
R
,
Cummings
CA
, editors.
Re-visioning psychiatry: cultural phenomenology, critical neuroscience, and global mental health
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
;
2015
. p.
41
64
.
3.
Marková
IS
,
Berrios
GE
.
Epistemology of mental symptoms
.
Psychopathology
.
2009
;
42
(
6
):
343
9
. https://doi.org/10.1159/000236905.
4.
Marková
IS
,
Berrios
GE
.
Epistemology of psychiatry
.
Psychopathology
.
2012
;
45
(
4
):
220
7
. https://doi.org/10.1159/000331599.
5.
Stanghellini
G
.
Psychopathology: re-humanizing psychiatry
.
Acta Psychiatr Scand
.
2013 Jun
;
127
(
6
):
436
7
. https://doi.org/10.1111/acps.12091.
6.
Andreasen
NC
.
DSM and the death of phenomenology in America: an example of unintended consequences
.
Schizophr Bull
.
2006 Dec
;
33
(
1
):
108
12
. https://doi.org/10.1093/schbul/sbl054.
7.
Parnas
J
,
Gallagher
S
.
Phenomenology and the interpretation of psychopathological experience
. In:
Kirmayer
LJ
,
Lemelson
R
,
Cummings
CA
, editors.
Re-visioning psychiatry: cultural phenomenology, critical neuroscience, and global mental health
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
;
2015
. p.
65
80
.
8.
Parnas
J
,
Sass
LA
,
Zahavi
D
.
Rediscovering psychopathology: the epistemology and phenomenology of the psychiatric object
.
Schizophr Bull
.
2013 Mar
;
39
(
2
):
270
7
. https://doi.org/10.1093/schbul/sbs153.
9.
Stanghellini
G
,
Broome
MR
.
Psychopathology as the basic science of psychiatry
.
Br J Psychiatry
.
2014 Sep
;
205
(
3
):
169
70
. https://doi.org/10.1192/bjp.bp.113.138974.
10.
World Psychiatric Association
.
WPA recommendations: principles and priorities for a framework for training psychiatrists
.
2017
. Available from: https://3ba346de-fde6-473f-b1da-536498661f9c.filesusr.com/ugd/e172f3_9e614f64a8ee4675b8b3dedbc6488686.pdf
11.
Volpe
U
,
Sass
H
.
Why, what and how should early career psychiatrists learn about phenomenological psychopathology?
In:
Fiorillo
A
,
Calliess
IT
,
Sass
H
, editors.
How to succeed in psychiatry: a guide to training and practice
.
Chichester, West Sussex
:
Wiley-Blackwell
;
2012
. p.
82
97
.
12.
Stanghellini
G
,
Fiorillo
A
.
Five reasons for teaching psychopathology
.
World Psychiatry
.
2015 Feb
;
14
(
1
):
107
8
. https://doi.org/10.1002/wps.20200.
13.
Jaspers
K
.
Psicopatología general [Allgemeine Psychopathologie]
. 5th ed.
México
:
Fondo de Cultura Económica
;
1993
.
14.
Etxeandia-Pradera
JI
,
Martinez-Uribe
D
,
Bellver-Pradas
F
,
Gonzalez-Piqueras
JC
,
Nacher
J
,
Aguilar
EJ
,
.
Training psychiatry residents in descriptive psychopathology: a systematic review
.
Psychopathology
.
2021
;
54
(
1
):
1
17
. https://doi.org/10.1159/000512791.
15.
Brenner
AM
.
Uses and limitations of simulated patients in psychiatric education
.
Acad Psychiatry
.
2009 Mar
;
33
(
2
):
112
9
. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ap.33.2.112.
16.
Fiorillo
A
,
Sampogna
G
,
Del Vecchio
V
,
Luciano
M
,
Ambrosini
A
,
Stanghellini
G
,
.
Education in psychopathology in Europe: results from a survey in 32 countries
.
Acad Psychiatry
.
2016 Apr
;
40
(
2
):
242
8
. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40596-015-0333-x.
17.
De Golia
SG
,
Corcoran
KM
.
Supervision in psychiatric practice: practical approaches across venues and providers
.
Washington, DC
:
American Psychiatric Association
;
2019
.
18.
Grant
J
,
Abdelrahmen
MYH
,
Zachariah
A
.
Curriculum design in context
. In:
Walsh
K
, editor.
Oxford textbook of medical education
.
Oxford University Press
;
2013
. p.
13
24
.
19.
Landeta
J
.
El método Delphi. Una técnica de previsión del futuro
.
Barcelona
:
Ariel
;
2002
.
20.
Landeta
J
.
Current validity of the Delphi method in social sciences
.
Technol Forecast Soc Change
.
2006 Jun
;
73
(
5
):
467
82
. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2005.09.002.
21.
Waggoner
J
,
Carline
JD
,
Durning
SJ
.
Is there a consensus on consensus methodology? Descriptions and recommendations for future consensus research
.
Acad Med
.
2016 May
;
91
(
5
):
663
8
. https://doi.org/10.1097/acm.0000000000001092.
22.
Wijngaarden
V
.
The application of ATLAS.ti in different qualitative data analysis strategies [Internet]
. Available from: https://atlasti.com/research-hub/the-application-of-atlas-ti-in-different-qualitative-data-analysis-strategies.
23.
Fereday
J
,
Muir-Cochrane
E
.
Demonstrating rigor using thematic analysis: a hybrid approach of inductive and deductive coding and theme development
.
Int J Qual Methods
.
2006 Mar
;
5
(
1
):
80
92
. https://doi.org/10.1177/160940690600500107.
24.
Xu
W
,
Zammit
K
.
Applying thematic analysis to education: a hybrid approach to interpreting data in practitioner research
.
Int J Qual Methods
.
2020 Jan
;
19
:
160940692091881
. https://doi.org/10.1177/1609406920918810.
25.
McDonald
N
,
Schoenebeck
S
,
Forte
A
.
Reliability and inter-rater reliability in qualitative research
.
Proc ACM Hum Comput Interact
.
2019 Nov
;
3
(
CSCW
):
1
23
. https://doi.org/10.1145/3359174.
26.
Braun
V
,
Clarke
V
.
Successful qualitative research
. 1st ed.
Sage Publications
;
2013
.
27.
Landeta
J
,
Matey
J
,
Ruíz
V
,
Galter
J
.
Results of a Delphi survey in drawing up the input-output tables for Catalonia
.
Technol Forecast Soc Change
.
2008 Jan
;
75
(
1
):
32
56
. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.techfore.2007.01.005.
28.
Oyebode
F
.
Sims’ symptoms in the mind: textbook of descriptive psychopathology
. 5th ed.
Saunders
;
2014
.
29.
Hamilton
M
.
Fish’s clinical psychopathology: signs and symptoms in psychiatry
. 2nd ed.
Bristol
:
Wright
;
1985
.
30.
Jansson
L
,
Nordgaard
J
.
The psychiatric interview for differential diagnosis
. 1st ed.
Cham
:
Springer International Publishing
;
2016
.
31.
Scharfetter
C
.
General psychopathology: an introduction
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
;
1980
.
32.
Berrios
GE
.
The history of mental symptoms: descriptive psychopathology since the nineteenth century
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
;
1996
.
33.
Berrios
GE
,
Porter
R
.
A history of clinical psychiatry: the origin and history of psychiatric disorders
.
London
:
Athlone Press
;
1995
.
34.
Jaspers
K
.
General psychopathology
.
Baltimore
:
The Johns Hopkins University Press
;
1997
.
35.
Schneider
K
.
Klinische Psychopathologie [Clinical Psychopathology]
. 8th ed.
Stuttgart
:
Thieme
;
1967
.
36.
Ey
H
.
Études psychiatriques [Psychiatric Studies]
.
Perpignan: Cercle de Recherche et d’édition Henri Ey (CREHEY)
;
2006
.
37.
Minkowski
E
.
Lived time: phenomenological and psychopathological studies
.
Evanston, Illinois
:
Northwestern University Press
;
2019
.
38.
Conrad
K
.
Die beginnende Schizophrenie [Incipient Schizophrenia]
.
Stuttgart
:
Thieme
;
1958
.
39.
Kretschmer
E
.
Der Sensitive Beziehungswahn [The Sensitive Delusion of Reference
. 4th ed.
Berlin Heidelberg
:
Springer
;
1966
.
40.
Marková
IS
.
Insight in psychiatry
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
;
2005
.
41.
Amador
X
,
David
AS
.
Insight and psychosis
. 2nd ed.
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
;
2004
.
42.
Sierra
M
.
Depersonalization: a new look at a neglected syndrome
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
;
2009
.
43.
Berrios
GE
.
Hacia una nueva epistemología de la Psiquiatría
.
Buenos Aires
:
Polemos
;
2011
.
44.
Luque
R
,
Villagrán
JM
.
Psicopatología descriptiva: nuevas tendencias
.
Madrid
:
Trotta
;
2000
.
45.
Vallejo Ruiloba
J
.
Introducción a la psicopatología y la psiquiatría
. 8th ed.
Barcelona
:
Elsevier Masson
;
2015
.
46.
Eguíluz
I
,
Segarra
R
.
Introducción a la Psicopatología. Una visión actualizada
. 3rd ed.
Madrid
:
Editorial Médica Panamericana
;
2013
.
47.
Ey
H
.
Estudios sobre los delirios
.
Madrid
:
Editorial Triacastela
;
1998
.
48.
Berrios
GE
,
Fuentenebro de Diego
F
.
Delirio: Historia, Clínica, Metateoría
.
Madrid
:
Trotta
;
1996
.
49.
Walton
H
.
Education and training in psychiatry
.
London
:
King Edward’s Hospital Fund, Oxford University Press
;
1986
.
50.
Kay
J
.
Handbook of psychiatry residency training
. 1st ed.
Washington DC
:
American Psychiatric Association
;
1991
.
51.
Rieder
RO
,
Mellman
LA
.
What and how to teach in the residency program
. In:
Kay
J
,
Silberman
EK
,
Pessar
LF
, editors.
Handbook of psychiatric education
.
Arlington, VA
:
American Psychiatric Publishing, Inc.
;
2005
. p.
143
63
.
52.
Gask
L
,
Coskun
B
,
Baron
D
.
Teaching psychiatry
.
Oxford
:
Wiley-Blackwell
;
2011
.
53.
Fiorillo
A
,
Volpe
U
,
Bhugra
D
.
Role and responsibilities of psychiatrists
. In:
Fiorillo
A
,
Volpe
U
,
Bhugra
D
, editors.
Psychiatry in practice: education, experience, and expertise
.
Oxford
:
Oxford University Press
;
2016
. p.
1
10
.
54.
Dias
MC
,
Riese
F
,
Tasman
A
.
Curriculum development for psychiatric training
. In:
Fiorillo
A
,
Volpe
U
,
Bhugra
D
, editors.
Psychiatry in practice: education, experience, and expertise
.
Oxford
;
2016
. p.
149
63
.
55.
Royal College of Physicians and Surgeons of Canada
.
CanMEDS objectives of training in the specialty of psychiatry [Internet]
.
2015
. Available from: https://www.royalcollege.ca/rcsite/documents/ibd/psychiatry_otr_e.pdf.
56.
The psychiatry milestone project
..
J Grad Med Educ
.
2014
;
6
(
1 Suppl 1
):
284
304
. DOI: 10.4300/JGME-06-01s1-11.
57.
Baron
D
,
Coskun
B
.
Psychiatrist educators
. In:
Gask
L
,
Coskun
B
,
Baron
D
, editors.
Teaching psychiatry
.
Oxford
:
Wiley-Blackwell
;
2011
. p.
247
59
.
58.
James
M
,
Hung
E
.
Supervision of trainees in the psychiatric emergency service
. In:
Riba
MB
,
Ravindranath
D
,
Winder
GS
, editors.
Clinical manual of emergency psychiatry
.
Arlington, VA
:
American Psychiatric Association
;
2016
. p.
295
326
.
59.
Santos
CW
,
Harper
A
,
Saunders
AE
,
Randle
SL
.
Developing a psychopathology curriculum during child and adolescent psychiatry residency training: general principles and a problem-based approach
.
Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am
.
2007 Jan
;
16
(
1
):
95
110
. https://doi.org/10.1016/j.chc.2006.07.007.
60.
Valdivieso
SA
,
Brockering
W
,
Mejias
M
,
Villarroel
L
,
Maldonado
G
,
Sirhan
M
.
Evaluación de un Modelo de Enseñanza de la Psicopatología para Residentes de Psiquiatría
.
ARS MEDICA Rev Ciencias Médicas
.
2016 Feb
;
40
(
1
):
19
27
.
61.
Lunn
B
,
Corral
MR
,
Mihai
A
.
Assessment in psychiatric education
. In:
Gask
L
,
Coskun
B
,
Baron
D
, editors.
Teaching psychiatry
.
Oxford
:
Wiley-Blackwell
;
2011
. p.
213
30
.
62.
Bleuler
M
,
Kerbikov
OV
,
Krapf
EE
,
Lambo
TA
,
Lebovici
S
,
Lin
TY
,
.
Teaching of psychiatry and mental health
.
Geneva
:
World Health Organization
;
1961
.
63.
Ajuriaguerra
J
,
Baan
P
,
Baasher
T
,
Ewalt
J
,
Lin
T
,
Snezhnevsky
A
,
.
Training of psychiatrists. Twelfth report of the expert committee on mental health
.
Geneva
:
World Health Organization
;
1963
.
64.
Bromley
E
,
Braslow
JT
.
Teaching critical thinking in psychiatric training: a role for the social sciences
.
Am J Psychiatry
.
2008 Nov
;
165
(
11
):
1396
401
. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ajp.2008.08050690.
65.
Stein
SP
.
Supervision of the initial interview
.
Arch Gen Psychiatry
.
1975 Feb
;
32
(
2
):
265
. https://doi.org/10.1001/archpsyc.1975.01760200129013.
66.
Chaslin
P
.
Elementos de semiología y clínica mentales [Élements de sémiologie et clinique mentales]
. 1st ed.
Buenos Aires
:
Polemos
;
2010
.
67.
Haigh
R
,
Lovell
K
.
Patients as teachers: involving service users
. In:
Gask
L
,
Coskun
B
,
Baron
D
, editors.
Teaching psychiatry
.
Oxford
:
Wiley-Blackwell
;
2011
. p.
177
89
.
68.
Malik
A
,
Bhugra
D
,
Brittlebank
A
.
Workplace-based assessments in psychiatry
. 2nd ed.
London
:
Royal College of Psychiatrists
;
2011
.
69.
Bhugra
D
,
Malik
A
.
Workplace-based assessments in psychiatric training
.
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
;
2011
.
70.
Yager
J
.
Major issues in psychiatric education
. In:
Kay
J
,
Silberman
EK
,
Pessar
LF
, editors.
Handbook of psychiatric education
.
Arlington, VA
:
American Psychiatric Publishing, Inc.
;
2005
. p.
333
60
.
71.
Hawkins
RE
,
Welcher
CM
,
Holmboe
ES
,
Kirk
LM
,
Norcini
JJ
,
Simons
KB
,
.
Implementation of competency-based medical education: are we addressing the concerns and challenges
.
Med Educ
.
2015
;
49
(
11
):
1086
102
. https://doi.org/10.1111/medu.12831.
72.
Young
JQ
,
Lieu
S
,
O’Sullivan
P
,
Tong
L
.
Development and initial testing of a structured clinical observation tool to assess pharmacotherapy competence
.
Acad Psychiatry
.
2011 Jan
;
35
(
1
):
27
34
. https://doi.org/10.1176/appi.ap.35.1.27.
73.
Young
JQ
,
Rasul
R
,
O’Sullivan
PS
.
Evidence for the validity of the psychopharmacotherapy-structured clinical observation tool: results of a factor and time series analysis
.
Acad Psychiatry
.
2018
;
42
(
6
):
759
64
. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40596-018-0928-0.
74.
Young
JQ
,
Irby
DM
,
Kusz
M
,
O’Sullivan
PS
.
Performance assessment of pharmacotherapy: results from a content validity survey of the psychopharmacotherapy-structured clinical observation (P-SCO) tool
.
Acad Psychiatry
.
2018
;
42
(
6
):
765
72
. https://doi.org/10.1007/s40596-017-0876-0.
75.
Holmboe
ES
,
Durning
SJ
,
Hawkins
RE
.
Practical guide to the evaluation of clinical competence
. 2nd ed.
Philadelphia, PA
:
Elsevier
;
2018
.
76.
University of Valencia
.
In order to carry out an opinion survey work, is the approval of The Committee of Ethics and Human Research necessary? [Internet]
. Available from: https://www.uv.es/ethical-commission-experimental-research/en/ethics-research-humans/preguntes-frequents.html.
You do not currently have access to this content.