Abstract
Purpose: Descriptive psychopathology (DP, sometimes called psychopathology or phenomenology) is the language of psychiatry and is dedicated to the description of mental symptoms. Due to its importance, there is an ongoing case to put it back at the heart of psychiatry and its training. This study seeks to examine the literature on how to train psychiatry residents in DP, including reported educational interventions and educational methods. Method: The authors conducted a systematic review following the PRISMA and BEME guidelines to identify literature on how to train psychiatry residents in DP. In May 2019, they searched in Embase, ERIC, PsycINFO, PubMed, Scopus, and Web of Science; of 7,199 initial results, 26 sources were finally included for analysis. The assessment tools were the CRAAP test, Kirkpatrick’s 4 levels, and (when applicable) the Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument (MERSQI). Results: The mean CRAAP score was 38.885 of a possible 50 (SD 0.983; range: 36.859–40.910). Fourteen sources (53.8%) had some kind of training evaluation: Kirkpatrick’s level 1 was present in nearly all (13) and was the highest in half of them (7). Regarding the educational interventions, the mean MERSQI score was 10.592 of a possible 18 (SD 2.371; range 9.085–12.098). Lectures were the most widely reported educational method (5); among those in clinical settings, the live supervised interview with feedback was the most usual (4). Conclusions: Despite its core importance as the language of psychiatry, the literature about training psychiatry residents in DP is scarce and heterogeneous. General lack of training evaluation and ongoing overemphasis on Kirkpatrick’s levels 1–2 at the expense of levels 3–4 are causes for concern. During the review process, the authors identified a selection of educational interventions that could serve as the basis for the design of new training efforts in both clinical and nonclinical settings. Topics for future research are also suggested, such as the role of DP in competency-based training frameworks now in vogue and a series of neglected contents. Finally, the combined use of the CRAAP test and the MERSQI may be useful for future systematic reviews in medical education.
References
1.
American Psychiatric Association
. What is psychiatry? [Internet]
. [cited 2019 Aug 11]. Available from: https://www.psychiatry.org/patients-families/what-is-psychiatry.2.
Berrios
GE
. The history of descriptive psychopathology
. In: Mezzich
JE
, Jorge
MR
, Salloum
IM
, editors. Psychiatric epidemiology: assessment concepts and methods
. Baltimore, MD
: The Johns Hopkins University Press
; 1994
. p. 47
–68
.3.
Berrios
GE
, Marková
IS
. Symptoms: historical perspective and effect on diagnosis
. In: Blumenfield
M
, Strain
JJ
, editors. Psychosomatic medicine
. Philadelphia, PA
: Lippincott Williams & Wilkins
; 2006
. p. 27
–38
.4.
Berrios
GE
. The history of mental symptoms: descriptive psychopathology since the nineteenth century
. Cambridge, England
: Cambridge University Press
; 1996
.5.
Marková
IS
, Berrios
GE
. Epistemology of mental symptoms
. Psychopathology
. 2009
;42
(6
):343
–9
. .6.
Berrios
GE
. History and epistemology of psychopathology
. In: Kendler
KS
, Parnas
J
, editors. Philosophical issues in psychiatry. III, the nature and sources of historical change
. Oxford, England
: Oxford University Press
; 2015
. p. 30
–50
.7.
Marková
IS
, Berrios
GE
. Epistemology of psychiatry
. Psychopathology
. 2012
;45
(4
):220
–7
. .8.
Berrios
GE
. Psychiatry and its objects
. Rev Psiquiatr Salud
. 2011 Oct
;4
(4
):179
–82
.9.
Fish
F
. Fish’s clinical psychopathology: signs and symptoms in psychiatry
. 2nd ed. Bristol, England
: Wright
; 1985
.10.
Berrios
GE
, Marková
IS
. Toward a new epistemology of psychiatry
. In: Kirmayer
LJ
, Lemelson
R
, Cummings
CA
, editors. Re-visioning psychiatry: cultural phenomenology, critical neuroscience, and global mental health
. Cambridge, England
: Cambridge University Press
; 2015
. p. 41
–64
.11.
Parnas
J
, Gallagher
S
. Phenomenology and the interpretation of psychopathological experience
. In: Kirmayer
LJ
, Lemelson
R
, Cummings
CA
, editors. Re-visioning psychiatry: cultural phenomenology, critical neuroscience, and global mental health
. Cambridge, England
: Cambridge University Press
; 2015
. p. 65
–80
.12.
Parnas
J
, Sass
LA
, Zahavi
D
. Rediscovering psychopathology: the epistemology and phenomenology of the psychiatric object
. Schizophr Bull
. 2013 Mar
;39
(2
):270
–7
. .13.
Parnas
J
. Foreword
. In: Jansson
L
, Nordgaard
J
, editors. The psychiatric interview for differential diagnosis
. 1st ed. Copenhagen, Denmark
: Springer
; 2016
. p. v
–vii
.14.
Stanghellini
G
. Psychopathology: re-humanizing psychiatry
. Acta Psychiatr Scand
. 2013 Jun
;127
(6
):436
–7
. .15.
Andreasen
NC
. DSM and the death of phenomenology in America: an example of unintended consequences
. Schizophr Bull
. 2006 Dec
;33
(1
):108
–12
.16.
Rossi
A
. Psychopathology: education, evidence and translation. the 23rd Congress of the Italian Society of Psychopathology
. J Psychopathol
. 2019 Mar
;25
(1
):1
–2
.17.
Insel
T
, Cuthbert
B
, Garvey
M
, Heinssen
R
, Pine
DS
, Quinn
K
, et al. Research Domain Criteria (RdoC): toward a new classification framework for research on mental disorders
. Am J Psychiatry
. 2010 Jul
;167
(7
):748
–51
. .18.
De Leon
J
. One hundred years of limited impact of Jaspers’ general psychopathology on US psychiatry
. J Nerv Ment Dis
. 2014
;202
(2
):79
–87
. .19.
De Leon
J
. DSM-5 and the Research Domain Criteria: 100 years after Jaspers’ general psychopathology
. Am J Psychiatry
. 2014 May
;171
(5
):492
–4
.20.
Kirmayer
LJ
, Crafa
D
. What kind of science for psychiatry?
Front Hum Neurosci
. 2014
;8
(435
):435
–12
. .21.
Lilienfeld
SO
, Treadway
MT
. Clashing diagnostic approaches: DSM-ICD versus RdoC
. Annu Rev Clin Psychol
. 2016
;12
:435
–463
.22.
Fuchs
T
. Ecology of the brain: the phenomenology and biology of the embodied mind
. Oxford, England
: Oxford University Press
; 2018
.23.
Berrios
GE
. Towards a new epistemology of psychiatry
. Buenos Aires, Argentina
: Polemos
; 2011
.24.
Stanghellini
G
, Broome
MR
. Psychopathology as the basic science of psychiatry
. Br J Psychiatry
. 2014 Sep
;205
(3
):169
–70
. .25.
Volpe
U
, Sass
H
. Why, what and how should early career psychiatrists learn about phenomenological psychopathology?
In: Fiorillo
A
, Calliess
IT
, Sass
H
, editors. How to succeed in psychiatry: a guide to training and practice
. 1st ed. Chichester, West Sussex
: Wiley-Blackwell
; 2012
. p. 82
–97
.26.
Stanghellini
G
, Fiorillo
A
. Five reasons for teaching psychopathology
. World Psychiatry
. 2015 Feb
;14
(1
):107
–8
. .27.
Marková
IS
, Chen
E
. Rethinking psychopathology
. Cham, Switzerland
: Springer
; 2020
.28.
De Leon
J
. Is psychiatry scientific? A letter to a 21st century psychiatry resident
. Psychiatry Investig
. 2013
;10
(3
):205
–17
. .29.
De Leon
J
. Is it time to awaken sleeping beauty? European psychiatry has been sleeping since 1980
. Rev Psiquiatr Salud
. 2014
;7
(4
):186
–94
. .30.
Morán-Barrios
J
. Un esid esidentsal para una nueva sociedad. respuestas desde la educación médica: la formación basada en competencias
. Rev Asoc Esp Neuropsiquiatr
. 2013
;33
(118
):385
–405
.31.
Wijnen-Meijer
M
, Burdick
W
, Alofs
L
, Burgers
C
, Ten Cate
O
. Stages and transitions in medical education around the world: clarifying structures and terminology
. Med Teach
. 2013
;35
(4
):301
–7
. .32.
Hudziak
JJ
. Crisis in American psychiatric education: an argument for the inclusion of research training for all psychiatric residents
. In: Zorumski
CF
, Rubin
EH
, editors. Psychopathology in the genome and neuroscience era
. Arlington, VA
: American Psychiatric Publishing, Inc.
; 2005
. p. 203
–28
, Chapter xiii, 239 Pages
.33.
Kirkpatrick
JD
, Kirkpatrick
WK
. Kirkpatrick’s four levels of training evaluation
. Alexandria, VA
: ATD Press
; 2016
.34.
Frenk
J
, Chen
L
, Bhutta
ZA
, Cohen
J
, Crisp
N
, Evans
T
, et al. Health professionals for a new century: transforming education to strengthen health systems in an interdependent world
. Lancet
. 2010
;376
(9756
):1923
–58
. .35.
Harden
M
, Grant
J
, Buck
RG
. BEME guide no. 1: best evidence medical education
. Med Teach
. 1999 Jan
;21
(6
):553
–62
.36.
Haig
A
, Dozier
M
. BEME guide no. 3: systematic searching for evidence in medical education: part 1: sources of information
. Med Teach
. 2003 Jan
;25
(4
):352
–63
. .37.
Haig
A
, Dozier
M
. BEME guide no. 3: systematic searching for evidence in medical education: part 2: constructing searches
. Med Teach
. 2003 Jan
;25
(5
):463
–84
. .38.
Hammick
M
, Dornan
T
, Steinert
Y
. Conducting a best evidence systematic review. Part 1: from idea to data coding. BEME guide no. 13
. Med Teach
. 2010 Jan
;32
(1
):3
–15
. .39.
Sharma
R
, Gordon
M
, Dharamsi
S
, Gibbs
T
. Systematic reviews in medical education: a practical approach: AMEE guide 94
. Med Teach
. 2015 Feb
;37
(2
):108
–24
. .40.
Liberati
A
, Altman
DG
, Tetzlaff
J
, Mulrow
C
, Gøtzsche
PC
, Ioannidis
JP
, et al. The PRISMA statement for reporting systematic reviews and meta-analyses of studies that evaluate healthcare interventions: explanation and elaboration
. BMJ
. 2009 Jul
;339
:b2700
. .41.
Bramer
WM
, Rethlefsen
ML
, Kleijnen
J
, Franco
OH
. Optimal database combinations for literature searches in systematic reviews: a prospective exploratory study
. Syst Rev
. 2017 Dec
;6
(1
):245
. .42.
Houpt
JL
, Weinstein
HM
, Russell
ML
. The application of competency-based education to consultation-liaison psychiatry: I. Data gathering and case formulation
. Int J Psychiatry Med
. 1977 Dec
;7
(4
):295
–307
.43.
Houpt
JL
, Weinstein
HM
, Russell
ML
. The application of competency-based education to consultation-liaison psychiatry: II. Intervention knowledge and skills
. Int J Psychiatry Med
. 1977 Dec
;7
(4
):309
–20
. .44.
Russell
ML
, Weinstein
HM
, Houpt
JL
. The application of competency-based education to consultation-liaison psychiatry: III. Implications
. Int J Psychiatry Med
. 1977 Dec
;7
(4
):321
–8
. .45.
Hung
E
, Azzam
A
. Supervision of trainees in the psychiatric emergency service
. In: Riba
MB
, Ravindranath
D
, editors. Clinical manual of emergency psychiatry
. Arlington, VA
: American Psychiatric Publishing, Inc
; 2010
. p. 315
–47
. Chapter xxvii, 406 Pages
.46.
James
M
, Hung
E
. Supervision of trainees in the psychiatric emergency service
. In: Riba
MB
, Ravindranath
D
, Winder
GS
, editors. Clinical manual of emergency psychiatry
. 2nd ed. Arlington, VA
: American Psychiatric Association
; 2016
. p. 295
–326
.47.
Sullivan
GM
. Deconstructing quality in education research
. J Grad Med Educ
. 2011 Jun
;3
(2
):121
–4
. .48.
Garcia
M
, Daugherty
C
, Ben Khallouq
B
, Maugans
T
. Critical assessment of pediatric neurosurgery patient/parent educational information obtained via the internet
. J Neurosurg Pediatr
. 2018
;21
(5
):535
–41
. .49.
Texas State University Libraries
. LibGuides: finding and evaluating web sources: the CRAAP test [Internet]
. 2019
[cited 2019 Oct 4]. Available from: https://guides.library.txstate.edu/c.php?g=184587&p=4604817.50.
Cook
DA
, Reed
DA
. Appraising the quality of medical education research methods: the Medical Education Research Study Quality Instrument and the Newcastle-Ottawa Scale-education
. Acad Med
. 2015
;90
(8
):1067
–76
. .51.
Kothari
D
, Gourevitch
MN
, Lee
JD
, Grossman
E
, Truncali
A
, Ark
TK
, et al. Undergraduate medical education in substance abuse: a review of the quality of the literature
. Acad Med
. 2011 Jan
;86
(1
):98
–112
. .52.
Stein
SP
, Karasu
TB
, Charles
ES
, Buckley
PJ
. Supervision of the initial interview. a study of two methods
. Arch Gen Psychiatry
. 1975 Feb
;32
(2
):265
. .53.
Willmuth
LR
, McKegney
FP
. A basic clinical skills tutorial for first-year psychiatric residents
. Acad Psychiatry
. 1977
;1
(2
):151
–6
. .54.
Janzen
CL
, Philips
I
, Malloy
M
. Child psychiatry education in early child development: description of a training program
. Child Psychiatry Hum Dev
. 1981
;11
(3
):158
–66
. .55.
Marin
RS
, Foster
JR
, Ford
CV
, Reifler
BV
, Reisberg
B
, Robinowitz
CB
, et al. A curriculum for education in geriatric psychiatry
. Am J Psychiatry
. 1988 Jul
;145
(7
):836
–43
. .56.
Shea
SC
, Mezzich
JE
, Bohon
S
, Zeiders
A
. A comprehensive and individualized psychiatric interviewing training program
. Acad Psychiatry
. 1989 Jun
;13
(2
):61
–72
. .57.
Halikas
JA
. Model curriculum for alcohol and drug abuse training and experience during the adult psychiatry residency
. Am J Addict
. 1992 Jan
;1
(3
):222
–9
. .58.
Hodes
M
. A core curriculum for child and adolescent psychiatry
. Eur Child Adolesc Psychiatry
. 1998 Dec
;7
(4
):250
–4
. .59.
Thompson
JW
. A curriculum for learning about American Indians and Alaska Natives in psychiatry residency training
. Acad Psychiatry
. 1996 Mar
;20
(1
):5
–14
.60.
Yates
WR
, Gerdes
TT
. Problem-based learning in consultation psychiatry
. Gen Hosp Psychiatry
. 1996 May
;18
(3
):139
–44
. .61.
Blass
DM
. A pragmatic approach to teaching psychiatry residents the assessment and treatment of religious patients
. Acad Psychiatry
. 2007 Feb
;31
(1
):25
–31
. .62.
Brenner
AM
. Uses and limitations of simulated patients in psychiatric education
. Acad Psychiatry
. 2009 Mar
;33
(2
):112
–9
. .63.
Bromley
E
, Braslow
JT
. Teaching critical thinking in psychiatric training: a role for the social sciences
. Am J Psychiatry
. 2008 Nov
;165
(11
):1396
–401
. .64.
Kirmayer
LJ
, Rousseau
C
, Guzder
J
, Jarvis
GE
. Training clinicians in cultural psychiatry: a Canadian perspective
. Acad Psychiatry
. 2008 Jul
;32
(4
):313
–9
. .65.
Nikapota
A
. Transcultural training in child and adolescent psychiatry
. In: Garralda
ME
, Raynaud
JP
, editors. Culture and conflict in child and adolescent mental health BT: culture and conflict in child and adolescent mental health
. Lanham, MD
: Jason Aronson
; 2008
. p. 205
–22
. Chapter xviii, 274 Pages
.66.
Santos
CW
, Harper
A
, Saunders
AE
, Randle
SL
. Developing a psychopathology curriculum during child and adolescent psychiatry residency training: general principles and a problem-based approach
. Child Adolesc Psychiatr Clin N Am
. 2007 Jan
;16
(1
):95
–110.
67.
Shea
SC
, Green
R
, Barney
C
, Cole
S
, Lapetina
G
, Baker
B
. Designing clinical interviewing training courses for psychiatric residents: a practical primer for interviewing mentors
. Psychiatr Clin North Am
. 2007 Jun
;30
(2
):283
–314
. .68.
Taylor
MA
, Vaidya
NA
. Psychopathology in neuropsychiatry: DSM and beyond
. J Neuropsychiatry Clin Neurosci
. 2005 May
;17
(2
):246
–9
. .69.
Etkin
A
, Cuthbert
B
. Beyond the DSM: development of a transdiagnostic psychiatric neuroscience course
. Acad Psychiatry
. 2014 Apr
;38
(2
):145
–50
. .70.
Fiorillo
A
, Sampogna
G
, Del Vecchio
V
, Luciano
M
, Ambrosini
A
, Stanghellini
G
. Education in psychopathology in Europe: results from a survey in 32 countries
. Acad Psychiatry
. 2016 Apr
;40
(2
):242
–8
.71.
Fluyau
D
. Integrating DSM/ICD, research domain criteria, and descriptive psychopathology in teaching and practice of psychiatry
. Front Psychiatry
. 2018 Oct
;9
(Oct
):484
. .72.
Luciano
M
, Del Vecchio
V
, Sampogna
G
, De Rosa
C
, Ambrosini
A
, Fiorillo
A
, et al. Training in psychopathology in Europe: results from a survey
. Eur Psychiatry
. 2015
;30
:676
. .73.
Sampogna
G
, Del Vecchio
V
, Luciano
M
, De Rosa
C
, Fiorillo
A
. Training in psychopathology in Europe: Are we doing well? A survey among early career psychiatrists
. J Psychopathol
. 2014 Dec
;20
(4
):377
–80
.74.
Tobia
A
, Draschil
T
, Sportelli
D
, Katsamanis
M
, Rosenberg
S
, Williams
JM
. The horror!: a creative framework for teaching psychopathology via metaphorical analyses of horror films
. Acad Psychiatry
. 2013 Mar
;37
(2
):131
–6
. .75.
Valdivieso
SA
, Brockering
W
, Mejias
M
, Villarroel
L
, Maldonado
G
, Sirhan
M
. Evaluación de un modelo de enseñanza de la psicopatología para esidents de psiquiatría
. ARS Med Rev Cienc Méd
. 2016 Feb
;40
(1
):19
–27
.76.
Lockyer
J
, Carraccio
C
, Chan
MK
, Hart
D
, Smee
S
, Touchie
C
, et al. Core principles of assessment in competency-based medical education
. Med Teach
. 2017 Jun
;39
(6
):609
–16
. .77.
Frank
JR
, Snell
L
, Englander
R
, Holmboe
ES
. On behalf of the ICBME collaborators. Implementing competency-based medical education: moving forward
. Med Teach
. 2017 Jun
;39
(6
):568
–73
.78.
WFME
. WFME global standards for quality improvement: postgraduate medical education. The 2015 revision
. Copenhagen, Denmark
: WFME
; 2015
.79.
Etxeandia-Pradera
JI
, Martinez-Uribe
D
, Bellver-Pradas
F
, Gonzalez-Piqueras
JC
, Aguilar
EJ
. The challenge of introducing competency-based psychiatry training in Spain
. Acad Psychiatry
. 2020 Dec
;44
(6
):770
–4
. .80.
BEME
. Steps in the review process: forming a review group [Internet]
. [cited 2019 Nov 29]. Available from: https://www.bemecollaboration.org/Step+2+Review+Group/.81.
Mombour
W
. Teaching psychopathology using the AMDP system in postgraduate education
. Acta Psychiatr Belg
. 1987
;87
(2
):159
–64
.© 2021 S. Karger AG, Basel
2021
Copyright / Drug Dosage / Disclaimer
Copyright: All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be translated into other languages, reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, microcopying, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Drug Dosage: The authors and the publisher have exerted every effort to ensure that drug selection and dosage set forth in this text are in accord with current recommendations and practice at the time of publication. However, in view of ongoing research, changes in government regulations, and the constant flow of information relating to drug therapy and drug reactions, the reader is urged to check the package insert for each drug for any changes in indications and dosage and for added warnings and precautions. This is particularly important when the recommended agent is a new and/or infrequently employed drug.
Disclaimer: The statements, opinions and data contained in this publication are solely those of the individual authors and contributors and not of the publishers and the editor(s). The appearance of advertisements or/and product references in the publication is not a warranty, endorsement, or approval of the products or services advertised or of their effectiveness, quality or safety. The publisher and the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to persons or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content or advertisements.
You do not currently have access to this content.
