Abstract
In a recent book Cristopher Bollas, one of the greatest contemporary psychoanalysts, tells about how he began to bring together phenomenology and psychoanalysis in the clinical setting at the beginning of his career. Working with psychotic patients, he realized that it was first necessary to “absorb” their view of reality before being able to reflect on the mad scenarios of psychosis. In what world did they live? How did they perceive it? Only by “mirroring” this back to the patients was it possible to offer them the experience of being in front of someone trying to understand their world view. Today, phenomenology has been spreading over psychoanalysis more than one can think it did in the past. The aim of this paper is to review and discuss the most relevant theoretical-clinical areas characterizing contemporary psychoanalysis in which phenomenology can claim a legitimate (or still illegitimate for someone) position. The main areas that will be discussed are: (a) the larger relational system or field in which human experience is continually shaped, i.e., the intersubjective matrix in which we are embedded; (b) the capacity to think about the “what” of the patients’ experience, rather than the “why” (especially with the most severely disturbed ones); and (c) the crisis of the primacy of interpretation in the analytical technique. Obviously, this review does not have the ambition to be exhaustive. Rather, it just wants to (re)open the discussion on a still controversial but very current topic.
References
1.
Bollas
C
. When the sun bursts. The enigma of schizophrenia. Yale
. Yale University
; 2015
.2.
Stolorow
RD
, Atwood
GE
. Contexts of Being: The Intersubjective Foundations of Psychological Life
. Hillsdale (NJ)
: The Analytic Press
; 1992
.3.
Stolorow
RD
. Dynamic, dyadic, intersubjective systems: an evolving paradigm for psychoanalysis
. Psychoanal Psychol
. 1997
;14
(3
):337
–46
. 0736-97354.
Stolorow
RD
, Atwood
GE
, Orange
DM
. Worlds of experience: Interweaving philosophical and clinical dimensions in psychoanalysis
. New York (NY)
: Basic Books
; 2002
.5.
Stolorow
RD
. Intersubjective-systems theory: A phenomenological-contextualist psychoanalytic perspective
. Psychoanal Dialogues
. 2013
;23
(4
):383
–9
. 1048-18856.
Stolorow
RD
, Atwood
GE
, Branchaft
B
. The intersubjective perspective
. Northvale (NJ)
: Jason Aronson
; 1994
.7.
Atwood
GE
, Stolorow
RD
. Structures of subjectivity: Explorations in psychoanalytic phenomenology and contextualism
. New York
: Routledge
; 2014
. 8.
Orange
DM
, Atwood
GE
, Stolorow
RD
. Working intersubjectively - Contextualism in psychoanalytic practice
. Hillsdale (NJ)
: The Analytic Press
; 1997
.9.
Zahavi
D
. Beyond empathy. Phenomenological approaches to intersubjectivity
. J Conscious Stud
. 2001
;8
(5-6
):151
–67
.1355-825010.
Sass
L
, Pienkos
E
. Faces of intersubjectivity
. J Phenomenological Psychol
. 2015
;46
(1
):1
–32
. 0047-266211.
Stanghellini
G
, Ballerini
M
, Mancini
M
. Other persons: on the phenomenology of interpersonal experience in schizophrenia (ancillary article to EAWE domain 3)
. Psychopathology
. 2017
;50
(1
):75
–82
.
[PubMed]
0254-496212.
Stanghellini
G
, Mancini
M
. The therapeutic interview in mental health: A values-based and person-centered approach
. Cambridge
: Cambridge University Press
; 2017
. 13.
Gallagher
S
. Intersubjectivity and psychopathology. In: Fulford
KW
, Davies
M
, Gipps
RG
, Graham
G
, Sadler
JZ
, Stanghellini
G
, et al., editors. The Oxford Handbook of Philosophy and Psychiatry
. Oxford
: Oxford University Press
; 2013
. pp. 258
–74
.14.
15.
Stolorow
RD
. World, affectivity, trauma: Heidegger and post-Cartesian psychoanalysis
. New York (NY)
: Routledge
; 2011
. 16.
17.
Hartmann
HP
. Psychoanalytic self psychology and its conceptual development in light of developmental psychology, attachment theory, and neuroscience
. Ann N Y Acad Sci
. 2009
Apr
;1159
(1
):86
–105
.
[PubMed]
0077-892318.
Stolorow
RD
, Atwood
GE
. The Power of Phenomenology: Psychoanalytic and Philosophical Perspectives
. New York
: Routledge
; 2018
. 19.
20.
Alvarez
A
: Livelli di lavoro analitico e livelli di patologia.
Paper read at Centro Psicoanalitico di Firenze, april 20th, 2002
.21.
Alvarez
A
. The thinking heart: Three levels of psychoanalytic therapy with disturbed children
. Hove
: Routledge
; 2012
. 22.
Bruner
J
. Processes of cognitive growth: Infancy
. Worcester
: Clark University Press
; 1968
.23.
Khan
M
. On lying fallow. Hidden selves: Between theory and practice in psychoanalysis
. London
: Hogarth Press
; 1977
. pp. 183
–8
.24.
Rossi Monti
M
. New interpretative styles: progress or contamination?: psychoanalysis and phenomenological psychopathology
. Int J Psychoanal
. 2005
Aug
;86
(Pt 4
):1011
–32
.
[PubMed]
0020-757825.
26.
Messas
G
, Tamelini
M
, Mancini
M
, Stanghellini
G
. New perspectives in phenomenological psychopathology: its use in psychiatric treatment
. Front Psychiatry
. 2018
Sep
;9
:466
.
[PubMed]
1664-064027.
Stern
DN
, Sander
LW
, Nahum
JP
, Harrison
AM
, Lyons-Ruth
K
, Morgan
AC
, et al.; The Process of Change Study Group
. Non-interpretive mechanisms in psychoanalytic therapy. The ‘something more’ than interpretation
. Int J Psychoanal
. 1998
Oct
;79
(Pt 5
):903
–21
.
[PubMed]
0020-757828.
Ferenczi
S
, Rank
O
. The Development of Psychoanalysis
. Madison (CT)
: Int. Univ. Press
; 1924
.29.
Strachey
J
. The nature of the therapeutic action of psychoanalysis. In: Bergmann
M
, Hartman
F
, editors. The evolution of psychoanalytic technique
. New York
: Basic Books
; 1934
. pp. 331
–60
.30.
Greenson
RR
. The technique and practice of psychoanalysis
. Volume I
. New York
: Int. Univ. Press
; 1967
.31.
Loewald
HW
. The transference neurosis: comments on the concept and the phenomenon
. J Am Psychoanal Assoc
. 1971
Jan
;19
(1
):54
–66
.
[PubMed]
0003-065132.
33.
Sandler
J
. Projection, identification, projective identification
. New York
: Int. Univ. Press
; 1987
.34.
35.
Greenberg
J
. Psychoanalytic words and psychoanalytic acts
. Contemp Psychoanal
. 1996
;32
(2
):195
–203
. 0010-753036.
Lyons-Ruth
K
, Bruschweiler-Stern
N
, Harrison
AM
, Morgan
AC
, Nahum
JP
, Sander
L
, et al. Implicit relational knowing: its role in development and psychoanalytic treatment
. Infant Ment Health J
. 1998
;19
(3
):282
–9
. 0163-964137.
Bruschweiler-Stern
N
, Lyons-Ruth
K
, Morgan
AC
, Nahum
JP
, Sander
LW
, Stern
DN
; BCPSG
. The foundational level of psychodynamic meaning: implicit process in relation to conflict, defense and the dynamic unconscious
. Int J Psychoanal
. 2007
Aug
;88
(Pt 4
):843
–60
.
[PubMed]
0020-757838.
Bruschweiler-Stern
N
, Harrison
AM
, Lyons-Ruth
K
, Morgan
AC
, Nahum
JP
, Sander
LW
, et al.; Boston Change Process Study Group
. Explicating the implicit: the local level and the microprocess of change in the analytic situation
. Int J Psychoanal
. 2002
Oct
;83
(Pt 5
):1051
–62
.
[PubMed]
0020-757839.
House
J
, Portuges
S
. Relational knowing, memory, symbolization, and language: commentary on the Boston Change Process Study Group
. J Am Psychoanal Assoc
. 2005
;53
(3
):731
–44
.
[PubMed]
0003-065140.
Litowitz
BE
. When “something more” is less: commentary on the Boston Change Process Study Group
. J Am Psychoanal Assoc
. 2005
;53
(3
):751
–9
.
[PubMed]
0003-065141.
Modell
AH
. Implicit or unconscious? Commentary on paper by the Boston Change Process Study Group
. Psychoanal Dialogues
. 2008
;18
(2
):162
–7
. 1048-188542.
43.
Bollas
C
. The Shadow of the Object: Psychoanalysis of the Unthought Known
. London, UK
: Free Association Book
; 1987
.44.
45.
Sander
L
. Paradox and resolution. In: Osofsky
J
, editor. Handbook of Child and Adolescent Psychiatry
. New York
: John Wiley
; 1997
. pp. 153
–60
.46.
Trevarthen
C
. Brain, science and the human spirit. In: Ashbrook
JB
, editor. Brain, Culture and the Human Spirit
. Lanham
: Univ. Press America
; 1993
. pp. 129
–81
.47.
Bohleber
W
. Between hermeneutics and natural science: Some focal points in the development of psychoanalytic clinical theory in Germany after 1945. In: Leuzinger-Bohleber
M
, Dreher
AU
, Canestri
J
, editors. Pluralism and Unity? Methods of Research in Psychoanalysis
. London
: International Psychoanalytical Association
; 2003
. pp. 63
–80
.48.
49.
McDaniel
K
. Edith Stein: On the problem of empathy. In: Schliesser
E
, editor. Ten neglected classics of philosophy
. Oxford
: Oxford University Press
; 2016
. pp. 195
–222
. 50.
51.
Kaes
R
. L’extension de la psychanalyse. Pour une métapsychologie de troisième type
. Paris
: Dunod
; 2015
. © 2019 S. Karger AG, Basel
2019
Copyright / Drug Dosage / Disclaimer
Copyright: All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be translated into other languages, reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, microcopying, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Drug Dosage: The authors and the publisher have exerted every effort to ensure that drug selection and dosage set forth in this text are in accord with current recommendations and practice at the time of publication. However, in view of ongoing research, changes in government regulations, and the constant flow of information relating to drug therapy and drug reactions, the reader is urged to check the package insert for each drug for any changes in indications and dosage and for added warnings and precautions. This is particularly important when the recommended agent is a new and/or infrequently employed drug.
Disclaimer: The statements, opinions and data contained in this publication are solely those of the individual authors and contributors and not of the publishers and the editor(s). The appearance of advertisements or/and product references in the publication is not a warranty, endorsement, or approval of the products or services advertised or of their effectiveness, quality or safety. The publisher and the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to persons or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content or advertisements.
You do not currently have access to this content.
