Communicative development can be better understood by examining the diversity of gestures and how various forms of gestures are interlinked in their developmental origins – their genealogy. To draw attention to the differences and interrelations among forms of gestures, we group gestures into three families based on their developmental origins: (1) action-based gestures that develop from infants’ spontaneous actions that others respond to; (2) conventional gestures; and (3) iconic gestures. Although these diverse gestures are acquired through somewhat different developmental pathways, we argue that they develop in the context of shared experiences within social routines. What differs is the relative role of the caregiver and child in initiating the routine. In viewing communicative development in this way, we show the importance of basing our investigations on an adequate conception of meaning in order to recognize the similarity in the underlying processes involved in early communicative development.

1.
Acredolo
L. P.
, &
Goodwyn
S. W.
1985
Symbolic gesturing in language development
.
Human Development
28
1
40
49
.
2.
Acredolo
L.
, &
Goodwyn
S.
1988
Symbolic gesturing in normal infants
.
Child Development
59
2
450
466
.
3.
Adamson
L. B.
,
Bakeman
R.
, &
Deckner
D.
2004
The development of symbol-infused joint engagement
.
Child Development
75
4
1171
1187
.
4.
Bakeman
R.
, &
Adamson
L. B.
1984
Coordinating attention to people and objects in mother-infant and peer-infant interaction
.
Child Development
55
4
1278
1289
.
5.
Baldwin
J. M.
1906
Thoughts and things
New York
the MacMillan Company
.
6.
Bates
E.
,
Camaioni
L.
, &
Volterra
V.
1975
The acquisition of performatives prior to speech
.
Merrill-Palmer Quarterly
21
3
205
226
.
7.
Bates
E.
,
Bretherton
I.
,
Snyder
L.
,
Shore
C.
, &
Volterra
V.
1979
The emergence of symbols: cognition and communication in infancy
.
Academic Press
.
8.
Behne
T.
,
Carpenter
M.
, &
Tomasello
M.
2014
Young children create iconic gestures to inform others
.
Developmental Psychology
50
8
2049
2060
.
9.
Bernstein
R. J.
2010
The pragmatic turn
.
Polity
.
10.
Bibok
M. B.
2011
Re-conceptualizing joint attention as social skills: A microgenetic analysis of the development of early infant communication
. [Unpublished doctoral dissertation,
Simon Fraser University
].
11.
Bickhard
M. H.
2004
The social ontology of persons
. In
J. I. M.
Carpendale
, &
U.
Müller
(Eds.),
Social interaction and the development of knowledge
. (pp.
111
132
Erlbaum
.
12.
Bruner
J.
1975
The ontogenesis of speech acts
.
Journal of Child Language
2
1
19
.
13.
Bruner
J.
1983
Child’s talk: Learning to use language
.
Norton
.
14.
Canfield
J. V.
1995
The rudiments of language
.
Language and Communication
15
3
195
211
.
15.
Canfield
J. V.
1999
Folk psychology versus philosophical anthropology
.
Idealistic Studies
3
153
171
.
16.
Canfield
J. V.
2007
Becoming human: The development of language, self, and self-consciousness
.
Palgrave Macmillan
.
17.
Carpendale
J. I. M.
2018
Communication as the coordination of activity: The implications of philosophical preconceptions for theories of the development of communication
. In
A. S.
Dick
, &
U.
Müller
(Eds.),
Advancing developmental science: Philosophy, theory, and method
. (pp.
145
156
Routledge, Taylor and Francis group
.
18.
Carpendale
J. I. M.
,
Atwood
S.
, &
Kettner
V.
2013
Meaning and mind from the perspective of dualist versus relational worldviews: Implications for the development of pointing gestures
.
Human Development
56
6
381
400
.
19.
Carpendale
J. I. M.
, &
Carpendale
A. B.
2010
The development of pointing: From personal directedness to interpersonal direction
.
Human Development
53
3
110
126
.
20.
Carpendale
J.I.
, &
Lewis
C.
2021
What makes us human. How minds develop through social interactions
.
Routledge
.
21.
Carpendale
J. I. M.
,
Müller
U.
,
Wallbridge
B.
,
Broesch
T.
,
Cameron-Faulkner
T.
, &
Ten Eycke
K.
2021
The development of giving in forms of object-exchange: Exploring the roots of communication and morality in early interaction around objects
.
Human Development
65
3
166
179
.
22.
Carpendale
J. I. M.
, &
Ten Eycke
K.
2020
From reflex to meaning via shared routines
. In
M. F.
Mascolo
, &
T. R.
Bidell
(Eds.),
Handbook of integrative psychological development: Essays in honor of Kurt W. Fischer
. (pp.
261
277
Routledge
.
23.
Chomsky
N.
2007
Biolinguistic explorations: Design, development, evolution
.
International Journal of Philosophical Studies
15
1
21
.
24.
Clark
R. A.
1978
The transition from action to gesture
. In
A.
Lock
(Ed.),
Action, gesture and symbol
(pp.
231
257
Academic Press
.
25.
Darwin
C.
1998
The expression of the emotions in man and animals
3rd ed.
HarperCollins Publishers
. (original work published 1872).
26.
Edwards
D.
1978
Social relations and early language
. In
A.
Lock
(Ed.),
Action, gesture and symbol
(pp.
449
469
Academic Press
.
27.
Eibl-Eibesfeldt
I.
1989
Human ethology
.
Routledge
.
28.
Efron
D.
1941
Gesture and environment
.
King’s Crown Press
.
29.
Ekman
P.
, &
Friesen
W. V.
1969
The repertoire of nonverbal behavior: Categories, origins, usage, and coding
.
Semiotica
1
1
49
98
.
30.
Fasolo
M.
, &
D’Odorico
L.
2012
Gesture-plus-word combinations, transitional forms, and language development
.
Gesture
12
1
1
15
.
31.
Geertz
C.
1973
The interpretation of cultures
.
Basic Books
.
32.
Goldberg
B.
1991
Mechanism and meaning
. In
J.
Hyman
(Ed.),
Investigating psychology: Sciences of the mind after Wittgenstein
. (pp.
48
66
Routledge
.
33.
Goldin-Meadow
S.
, &
Feldman
H.
1977
The development of language-like communication without a language model
.
Science
197
4301
401
.
34.
Gopnik
A.
, &
Wellman
H. M.
2012
Reconstructing constructivism: Causal models, Bayesian learning mechanisms, and the theory theory
.
Psychological Bulletin
136
.
35.
Guevara
I.
,
Moreno-Llanos
I.
, &
Rodríguez
C.
2020
The emergence of gestures in the first year of life in the infant school classroom
.
European Journal of Psychology of Education
35
2
265
287
.
36.
Guevara
I.
, &
Rodríguez
C.
2023
Developing communication through objects: Ostensive gestures as the first gestures in children’s development
.
Developmental Review
68
101076
.
37.
Hay
D. F.
, &
Murray
P.
1982
Giving and requesting: Social facilitation of infants’ offers to adults
.
Infant Behavior and Development
5
2-4
301
310
.
38.
Iverson
J. M.
,
Capirci
O.
, &
Caselli
M. C.
1994
From communication to language in two modalities
.
Cognitive development
9
1
23
42
.
39.
Jopling
D.
1993
Cognitive science, other minds, and the philosophy of dialogue
. In
U.
Neisser
(Ed.),
The perceived self
. (pp.
290
309
MIT Press
.
40.
Kaye
K.
1982
The mental and social life of babies
.
Hemel Hempstead
.
Harvester Wheatsheaf
.
41.
Kendon
A.
1992
Some recent work from Italy on “Quotable Gestures (Emblems)”
.
Journal of Linguistic Anthropology
2
1
92
108
.
42.
Kettner
V. A.
, &
Carpendale
J. I. M.
2018
From touching to communicating: Forms of index finger use in the development of pointing
.
Gesture
17
2
245
268
.
43.
Kettner
V. A.
, &
Carpendale
J. I. M.
2013
Developing gestures for no and yes: Head shaking and nodding in infancy
.
Gesture
13
2
193
209
.
44.
Kirk
E.
,
Howlett
N.
,
Pine
K. J.
, &
Fletcher
B.
2013
To sign or not to sign? The impact of encouraging infants to gesture on infant language and maternal mind-mindedness
.
Child Development
84
2
574
590
.
45.
Lakatos
I.
1970
Falsification and the methodology of scientific research programmes
. In
I.
Lakatos
, &
A.
Musgrave
(Eds.),
Criticism and the growth of knowledge
. (pp.
91
196
Cambridge University Press
.
46.
Leslie
A. M.
1987
Pretense and representation: The origins of “theory of mind”
.
Psychological Review
94
4
412
426
.
47.
Liebal
K.
,
Behne
T.
,
Carpenter
M.
, &
Tomasello
M.
2009
Infants use shared experience to interpret pointing gestures
.
Developmental Science
12
2
264
271
.
48.
Lock
A.
1978
The emergence of language
. In
A.
Lock
(Ed.),
Action, gesture and symbol
(pp.
3
18
Academic Press
.
49.
Lock
A.
1992
Anecdotal occurrences may be really important events
.
Human Movement Sciences
11
4
497
504
.
50.
McDonough
R.
1989
Towards a non-mechanistic theory of meaning
.
Mind
98
389
1
21
.
51.
McGregor
K.K.
, &
Capone
N.C.
2004
Genetic and environmental interactions in determining the early lexicon: Evidence from a set of tri-zygotic quadruplets
.
Journal of Child Language
31
2
311
337
.
52.
Mead
G. H.
1934
Mind, self and society: From the standpoint of a social behaviorist
.
University of Chicago Press
.
53.
Meltzoff
A. N.
2011
Social cognition and the origin of imitation, empathy, and theory of mind
. In
U.
Goswami
(Ed.),
Wiley-Blackwell handbook of childhood cognitive development
2nd ed., pp.
49
75
Wiley-Blackwell
.
54.
Müller
U.
, &
Carpendale
J. I. M.
2004
From joint activity to joint attention: A relational approach to social development in infancy
. In
J. I. M.
Carpendale
, &
U.
Müller
(Eds.),
Social interaction and the development of knowledge
(pp.
215
238
Erlbaum
.
55.
Murillo
E.
, &
Casla
M.
2020
Multimodal representational gestures in the transition to multi-word productions
.
Infancy
26
1
104
122
.
56.
Namy
L. L.
2008
Recognition of iconicity doesn’t come for free
.
Developmental Science
11
6
841
846
.
57.
Nelson
K.
2007
Young minds in social worlds: Experience, meaning, and memory
.
Harvard University Press
.
58.
Nelson
L. H.
,
White
K. R.
, &
Grewe
J.
2012
Evidence for website claims about the benefits of teaching sign language to infants and toddlers with normal hearing
.
Infant and Child Development
21
5
474
502
.
59.
Newson
J.
, &
Newson
E.
1975
Intersubjectivity and the transmission of culture
.
Bulletin of the British Psychological Society
28
437
445
.
60.
Ollas
D.
,
Rautakoski
P.
,
Nolvi
S.
,
Karlsson
H.
, &
Karlsson
L.
2020
Temperament is associated with the use of communicative gestures in infancy
.
Infant and Child Development
29
3
e2166
.
61.
Özçaliskan
S.
, &
Goldin-Meadow
S.
2009
When gesture-speech combinations do and do not index linguistic change
.
Language and Cognitive Processes
24
2
190
217
.
62.
Paulus
M.
,
Kammermeier
M.
, &
Melzel
S.
2023
The emergence of pointing as a communicative gesture: Age-related differences in infants’ non-social and social use of the index finger
.
Cognitive Development
65
101298
.
63.
Pinker
S.
1994
The language instinct: How the mind creates language
.
HarperPerennial
.
64.
Racine
T. P.
, &
Carpendale
J. I. M.
2008
The embodiment of mental states
. In
W. F.
Overton
,
U.
Müller
, &
J.
Newman
(Eds.),
Developmental perspectives on embodiment and consciousness
(pp.
159
190
Erlbaum
.
65.
Ramenzoni
V. C.
, &
Liszkowski
U.
2016
The social reach: 8-month-olds reach for unobtainable objects in the presence of another person
.
Psychological Science
27
9
1278
1285
.
66.
Reddy
V.
,
Markova
G.
, &
Wallot
S.
2013
Anticipatory adjustments to being picked up in infancy
.
PLoS One
8
6
1
9
.
67.
Rodríguez
C.
2009
The “circumstances” of gestures: Proto-interrogatives and private gestures
.
New Ideas in Psychology
27
2
288
303
.
68.
Rodríguez
C.
, &
Palacios
P.
2007
Do private gestures have a self-regulatory function? A case study
.
Infant Behavior and Development
30
2
180
194
.
69.
Rodríguez
C.
, &
Moro
C.
1999
El mágico número tres: cuando los niños aún no hablan [The magic number three: when children do not speak yet]
. Paidós.
70.
Savage-Rumbaugh
E. S.
1986
Ape language: From conditioned response to symbol
.
Columbia University Press
.
71.
Scheler
M.
1954
The nature of sympathy
. Translated by: P. Heath:
Archon Books
. (Original work published 1913).
72.
Shinn
M. W.
1900
The biography of a baby
.
Mifflin Company
. (re-published 1975).
73.
Spitz
R. A.
1957
No and yes: On the genesis of human communication
.
International Universities Press, Inc
.
74.
Tamis-LeMonda
C.
,
Kuchirko
Y.
, &
Song
L.
2014
Why is infant language learning facilitated by parental responsiveness
.
Current Directions in Psychological Science
23
121
121
126
.
75.
Tamis-LeMonda
C.
,
Custode
S.
,
Kuchirki
Y.
,
Escobar
K.
, &
Lo
T.
2016
Routine language: Speech directed to infants during home activities
.
Child Development
1
18
.
76.
Tomasello
M.
2003
Constructing a language: A usage-based theory of language acquisition
.
Harvard University Press
.
77.
Tomasello
M.
, &
Carpenter
M.
2013
Dueling dualists
.
Human Development
56
6
401
405
.
78.
Tomasello
M.
,
Carpenter
M.
,
Call
J.
,
Behne
T.
, &
Moll
H.
2005
Understanding and sharing intentions: The origins of cultural cognition
.
Behavioral and Brain Sciences
28
5
675
735
.
79.
Tomasello
M.
,
Carpenter
M.
, &
Liszkowski
U.
2007
A new look at infant pointing
.
Child Development
78
3
705
722
.
80.
Vallotton
C. D.
2012
Infant signs as intervention? Promoting symbolic gestures for preverbal children in low-income families to support responsive parent-child relationships
.
Early Childhood Research Quarterly
27
3
401
415
.
81.
Wallbridge
B.
2022
The development of object extension gestures: An action-based approach
. [Unpublished Master’s Degree Thesis,
Simon Fraser University
].
82.
Wermelinger
S.
,
Gampe
A.
,
Helbling
N.
, &
Daum
M.M.
2020
Do you understand what I want to tell you? Early sensitivity in bilinguals’ iconic gesture perception and production
.
Developmental Science
23
5
1
14
.
83.
Wills
G.
2001
Saint Augustine’s childhood: Confessiones
.
Book One
.
84.
Wilkins
D.
2003
Why pointing with the index finger is not a universal (in sociocultural and semiotic terms)
. In
S.
Kita
(Ed.),
Pointing: Where language, culture, and cognition meet
(pp.
171
215
Erlbaum
.
85.
Winch
P.
1958
The idea of a social science and its relation to philosophy
.
Routledge and Kegan Paul
.
86.
Wittgenstein
L.
1976
Cause and effect: Intuitive awareness
.
Philosophia
6
3-4
409
425
.
87.
Wittgenstein
L.
1980a
Culture and value
.
The University of Chicago Press
.
88.
Wittgenstein
L.
1980b
Remarks on the philosophy of psychology
Vol. I
Blackwell
.
89.
Wittgenstein
L.
2009
Philosophical investigations
. Translation by: G.E.M. Anscombe, P.M.S. Hacker & J. Schulte (Revised 4th ed.
Wiley-Blackwell
. (original work published 1953).
90.
Zahavi
D.
2008
Simulation, projection and empathy
.
Consciousness and Cognition
17
2
514
522
.
91.
Zinober
B.
, &
Martlew
M.
1985
Developmental changes in four types of gesture in relation to acts and vocalizations from 10 to 21 months
.
British Journal of Developmental Psychology
3
293
306
.
You do not currently have access to this content.