Currently, a central problem for theoretical biology is the integration of development with genetics and evolutionary theory. Through the late 20th century, biologists held that animals resemble their ancestors strictly because of the transgenerational transmission of DNA. This view effectively wrote development out of evolutionary biology. However, many molecular and developmental biologists now understand that phenotypes – anatomical, physiological, and behavioral traits – are not determined by genes (i.e., DNA segments) alone; instead, they emerge epigenetically from developmental processes involving co-acting genetic factors, environmental factors, molecular epigenetic factors, and other non-genetic factors within organisms’ bodies. This insight forces a rethinking of biological inheritance. Perspectives focusing on the dynamics of developmental systems offer a compelling alternative way to think about inheritance, providing a powerful substitute to the reductionistic framework that attributes phenotypic outcomes to genetic instructions set in advance of developmental processes. Rethinking genetics, epigenetics, and inheritance by focusing on the dynamics of developmental systems helps highlight the bidirectional effects of evolutionary and developmental processes on one another, yielding a more integrated understanding of development, inheritance, and evolution. Simultaneously, this approach encourages rejection of genetic determinism, a simplistic perspective that continues to appear in psychological writing, despite its biological implausibility.

1.
Amundson
R.
2005
The changing role of the embryo in evolutionary thought
.
Cambridge University Press
.
2.
Anway
M. D.
,
Cupp
A. S.
,
Uzumcu
M.
, &
Skinner
M. K.
2005
Epigenetic transgenerational actions of endocrine disruptors on male fertility
.
Science
308
5727
1466
1467
.
3.
Anway
M. D.
, &
Skinner
M. K.
2006
Epigenetic transgenerational actions of endocrine disruptors
.
Endocrinology
147
6 Suppl
S43
S49
.
4.
Aristotle
1984
). In
J.
Barnes
(Ed),
The complete works of Aristotle, the revised Oxford translations
Vol. 1
Princeton University Press
.
5.
Avital
E.
, &
Jablonka
E.
2000
Animal traditions: Behavioural inheritance in evolution
.
Cambridge University Press
.
6.
Baedke
J.
2018
Above the gene beyond biology: Toward a philosophy of epigenetics
.
University of Pittsburgh Press
.
7.
Baedke
J.
, &
Gilbert
S. F.
2021
Evolution and development
. In
E. N.
Zalta
(Ed),
The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy
. Fall 2021 Edition. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2021/entries/evolution-development/.
8.
Bonduriansky
R.
, &
Day
T.
2018
Extended heredity: A new understanding of inheritance and evolution
.
Princeton University Press
.
9.
Bull
J. J.
1980
Sex determination in reptiles
.
Quarterly Review of Biology
55
1
3
21
.
10.
Burggren
W. W.
, &
Crews
D.
2014
Epigenetics in comparative biology: Why we should pay attention
.
Integrative and Comparative Biology
54
1
7
20
.
11.
Champagne
F. A.
, &
Meaney
M. J.
2006
Stress during gestation alters postpartum maternal care and the development of the offspring in a rodent model
.
Biological Psychiatry
59
12
1227
1235
.
12.
Champagne
F. A.
,
Weaver
I. C. G.
,
Diorio
J.
,
Dymov
S.
,
Szyf
M.
, &
Meaney
M. J.
2006
Maternal care associated with methylation of the estrogen receptor-α1b promoter and estrogen receptor-α expression in the medial preoptic area of female offspring
.
Endocrinology
147
6
2909
2915
.
13.
Chang
H. S.
,
Anway
M. D.
,
Rekow
S.
, &
Skinner
M. K.
2006
Transgenerational epigenetic imprinting of the male germline by endocrine disruptor exposure during gonadal sex determination
.
Endocrinology
147
12
5524
5541
.
14.
Clark
M. M.
, &
Galef
B. G.
1995
A gerbil’s dam’s fetal intrauterine position affects the sex ratios of the litters she gestates
.
Physiology and Behavior
57
2
297
299
.
15.
Clark
M. M.
,
Karpiuk
P.
, &
Galef
B. G.
1993
Hormone mediated inheritance of acquired characteristics in Mongolian gerbils
.
Nature
364
6439
712
.
16.
Crews
D.
2010
Epigenetics, brain, behavior, and the environment
.
Hormones
9
1
41
50
.
17.
Crews
D.
2011
Epigenetic modifications of brain and behavior: Theory and practice
.
Hormones and Behavior
59
3
393
398
.
18.
Danchin
E.
,
Charmantier
A.
,
Champagne
F.
,
Mesouli
A.
,
Pulol
B.
, &
Blanchet
S.
2011
Beyond DNA: Integrating inclusive inheritance into an extended theory of evolution
.
Nature Reviews: Genetics
12
475
486
.
19.
Darwin
C.
1859/1991
On the origin of species by means of natural selection
.
Prometheus Books
.
20.
Davidson
E. H.
2001
Genomic regulatory systems: Development and evolution
.
Academic Press
.
21.
Daxinger
L.
, &
Whitelaw
E.
2012
Understanding transgenerational epigenetic inheritance via the gametes in mammals
.
Nature Reviews: Genetics
13
3
153
162
.
22.
Denenberg
V. H.
, &
Rosenberg
K. M.
1967
Nongenetic transmission of information
.
Nature
216
5115
549
550
.
23.
Denenberg
V. H.
, &
Whimbey
A. C.
1963
Behavior of adult rats is modified by the experience their mothers had as infants
.
Science
142
3596
1192
1193
.
24.
Dias
B. G.
, &
Ressler
K. J.
2014
Parental olfactory experience influences behavior and neural structure in subsequent generations
.
Nature Neuroscience
17
1
89
96
.
25.
Dobzhansky
T.
1951
Genetics and the origin of species
3rd ed.
Columbia University Press
.
26.
Francis
D. D.
,
Diorio
J.
,
Liu
D.
, &
Meaney
M. J.
1999
Nongenomic transmission across generations in maternal behavior and stress responses in the rat
.
Science
286
5442
1155
1158
.
27.
Franklin
T. B.
,
Russig
H.
,
Weiss
I. C.
,
Graff
J.
,
Linder
N.
,
Michalon
A.
et al
2010
Epigenetic transmission of the impact of early stress across generations
.
Biological Psychiatry
68
5
408
415
.
28.
Gerhart
J.
, &
Kirschner
M.
1997
Cells, embryos, and evolution
.
Blackwell Scientific
.
29.
Gerson
E. M.
2007
The juncture of evolutionary and developmental biology
. In
M. D.
Laubichler
, &
J.
Maienschein
(Eds),
From embryology to evo-devo: A history of developmental evolution
(pp.
435
463
MIT Press
.
30.
Gilbert
S. F.
1992
Cells in search of community: Critiques of Weismannism and selectable units in ontogeny
.
Biology and Philosophy
7
4
473
487
.
31.
Gilbert
S. F.
2005
Mechanisms for the environmental regulation of gene expression: Ecological aspects of animal development
.
Journal of Biosciences
30
1
65
74
.
32.
Gilbert
S. F.
, &
Epel
D.
2015
Ecological developmental biology: The environmental regulation of development, health, and evolution
2nd ed.
Sinauer Associates, Inc
.
33.
Goodwin
B.
1994
How the leopard changed its spots: The evolution of complexity
.
Charles Scribner
.
34.
Gottlieb
G.
1971
Development of species identification in birds: An inquiry into the prenatal determinants of perception
.
University of Chicago Press
.
35.
Gottlieb
G.
1998
Normally occurring environmental and behavioral influences on gene activity: From central dogma to probabilistic epigenesis
.
Psychological Review
105
4
792
802
.
36.
Gottlieb
G.
2001
The relevance of developmental–psychobiological metatheory to developmental neuropsychology
.
Developmental Neuropsychology
19
1
1
9
.
37.
Gottlieb
G.
2002
Emergence of the developmental manifold concept from an epigenetic analysis of instinctive behavior
. In
D.
Lewkowicz
, &
R.
Lickliter
(Eds),
Conceptions of development: Lessons from the laboratory
(pp.
31
56
Psychology Press
.
38.
Gottlieb
G.
,
Wahlsten
D.
, &
Lickliter
R.
2006
The significance of biology for human development: A developmental psychobiological systems view
. In
W.
Damon
, &
R.
M Lerner
(Eds),
Handbook of child psychology
5th ed., pp.
210
257
John Wiley Publishers
.
39.
Gould
S. J.
1977
Ontogeny and phylogeny
.
The Belknap Press of Harvard University Press
.
40.
Gray
R.
1992
Death of the gene: Developmental systems strike back
. In
P. E.
Griffiths
(Ed),
Trees of Life
.
Kluwer
.
41.
Griffiths
P. E.
, &
Gray
R. D.
1994
Developmental systems and evolutionary explanation
.
The Journal of Philosophy
XCI
6
277
304
.
42.
Hall
B. K.
1992
Waddington’s legacy in development and evolution
.
American Zoologist
32
1
113
122
.
43.
Hallgrimsson
B.
, &
Hall
B. K.
2011
Epigenetics: Linking genotype and phenotype in development and evolution
.
University of California Press
.
44.
Helanterä
H.
, &
Uller
T.
2010
The Price Equation and extended inheritance
.
Philosophy, Theory, and Practice in Biology
2
E101
.
45.
Henikoff
S.
, &
Greally
J. M.
2016
Epigenetics, cellular memory and gene regulation
.
Current Biology
26
14
R644
R648
.
46.
Ho
D. H.
2014
Transgenerational epigenetics: The role of maternal effects on cardiovascular development
.
Integrative and Comparative Biology
54
1
43
51
.
47.
Ho
D. H.
, &
Burggren
W. W.
2010
Epigenetics and transgenerational transfer: A physiological perspective
.
Journal of Experimental Biology
213
1
3
16
.
48.
Huxley
J.
1942
Evolution, the Modern Synthesis
.
Allen & Unwin
.
49.
Jablonka
E.
2007
The development construction of heredity
.
Developmental Psychobiology
49
8
808
817
.
50.
Jablonka
E.
, &
Lamb
M. J.
1995
Epigenetic inheritance and evolution
.
Oxford University Press
.
51.
Jablonka
E.
, &
Lamb
M. J.
2002
The changing concept of epigenetics
.
Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
981
82
96
.
52.
Jablonka
E.
, &
Lamb
M. J.
2005
Evolution in four dimensions: Genetic, epigenetic, behavioral, and symbolic variation in the history of life
.
MIT Press
.
53.
Jablonka
E.
, &
Lamb
M. J.
2007
Précis of Evolution in Four Dimensions
.
Behavioral and Brain Sciences
30
4
353
392
.
54.
Jablonka
E.
, &
Raz
G.
2009
Transgenerational epigenetic inheritance: Prevalence, mechanisms, and implications for the study of heredity and evolution
.
Quarterly Review of Biology
84
2
131
176
.
55.
Johannsen
W.
1911
The genotype conception of heredity
.
American Naturalist
45
531
129
159
.
56.
Johnston
T. D.
, &
Edwards
L.
2002
Genes, interactions, and the development of behavior
.
Psychological Review
109
1
26
34
.
57.
Kampourakis
K.
2021
Understanding Genes
.
Cambridge University Press
.
58.
Laland
K. N.
,
Uller
T.
,
Feldman
M. W.
,
Sterelny
K.
,
Müller
G. B.
,
Moczek
A.
,
Jablonka
E.
, &
Odling-Smee
J.
2015
The extended evolutionary synthesis: Its structure, assumptions and predictions
.
Proceedings of the Royal Society of London Series B: Biological Sciences
282
1813
20151019
.
59.
Laland
K. N.
,
Uller
T.
,
Feldman
M. W.
,
Sterelny
K.
,
Müller
G. B.
,
Moczek
A.
,
Jablonka
E.
,
Odling-Smee
J.
,
Wray
G. A.
,
Hoekstra
H. E.
,
Futuyma
D. J.
,
Lenski
R. E.
,
Mackay
T. F. C.
,
Schluter
D.
, &
Strassmann
J. E.
2014
Does evolutionary theory need a rethink
.
Nature
514
7521
161
164
.
60.
Laubichler
M. D.
, &
Maienschein
J.
2007
From embryology to evo-devo: A history of developmental evolution
.
MIT Press
.
61.
Lickliter
R.
2000
An ecological approach to behavioral development: Insights from comparative psychology
.
Ecological Psychology
12
4
319
334
.
62.
Lickliter
R.
, &
Honeycutt
H.
2015
Biology, development, and human systems. In
W. F.
Overton
, &
P. C. M.
Molenaar
(Eds.),
Handbook of child psychology and developmental science
7th ed.,
Vol. 1: Theory & method
, pp.
162
207
Wiley Blackwell
.
63.
Lickliter
R.
, &
Honeycutt
H.
2020
Epigenesis without preformationism: Taking development seriously
. In
M. F.
Mascola
, &
T. R.
Bidell
(Eds),
Handbook of integrative psychological development: Essays in honor of Kurt Fischer
(pp.
191
207
Routledge
.
64.
Lickliter
R.
, &
Witherington
D.C.
2017
Towards a truly developmental epigenetics
.
Human Development
60
124
138
.
65.
Lillycrop
K. A.
, &
Burge
G. C.
2015
Maternal diet as a modifier of offspring epigenetics
.
Journal of the Developmental Origins of Health and Disease
6
2
88
95
.
66.
Mameli
M.
2005
The inheritance of features
.
Biology and Philosophy
20
2-3
365
399
.
67.
Mayr
E.
1982
The growth of biological thought: Diversity, evolution, and inheritance
.
Harvard University Press
.
68.
Mennella
J. A.
,
Jagnow
C. P.
, &
Beauchamp
G. K.
2001
Prenatal and postnatal flavor learning by human infants
.
Pediatrics
107
6
e88
.
69.
Moore
D. S.
2002
The dependent gene: The fallacy of nature vs. nurture
.
W.H. Freeman
.
70.
Moore
D. S.
2008
Individuals and populations: How biology’s theory and data have interfered with the integration of development and evolution
.
New Ideas in Psychology
26
3
370
386
.
71.
Moore
D. S.
2015
The developing genome: An introduction to behavioral epigenetics
.
Oxford University Press
.
72.
Moore
D. S.
2016
Behavioral epigenetics
.
WIREs Systems Biology and Medicine
9
1
73.
Moore
D. S.
2017
The potential of epigenetics research to transform conceptions of phenotype development
.
Human Development
60
2-3
69
80
.
74.
Moore
D. S.
2023
On the evolution of epigenetics via exaptation: A developmental systems perspective. Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences
1
12
.
75.
Moore
D. S.
, &
Flom
R.
2020
Epigenetics and behavioral development
.
Infant Behavior and Development
61
101477
.
76.
Moore
D. S.
, &
Lickliter
R.
2023
Development as explanation: Understanding phenotypic stability and variability after the failure of genetic determinism
.
Progress in Biophysics and Molecular Biology
178
72
77
.
77.
Müller
G. B.
, &
Newman
S. A.
2003
Origination of organismal form: Beyond the gene in developmental and evolutionary biology
.
MIT Press
.
78.
Nanney
D. L.
1958
Epigenetic control systems
.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences
44
7
712
717
.
79.
Narvaez
D.
,
Moore
D. S.
,
Witherington
D. C.
,
Vandiver
T. I.
, &
Lickliter
R.
2022
Evolving evolutionary psychology
.
American Psychologist
77
3
424
438
.
80.
Newman
S. A.
, &
Müller
G. B.
2000
Epigenetic mechanisms of character origination
.
Journal of Experimental Zoology
288
4
304
317
.
81.
Nijhout
H. F.
1990
Problems and paradigms: Metaphors and the role of genes in development
.
Bioessays
12
9
441
446
.
82.
Noble
D.
2006
The dance of life: Biology beyond the genome
.
Oxford University Press
.
83.
Noble
D.
2008
Genes and causation
.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society A
366
1878
3001
3015
.
84.
Oyama
S.
1985/2000
The ontogeny of information
.
Duke University Press
.
85.
Oyama
S.
1999
Locating development, locating developmental systems. In
E.
Scholnick
,
K.
Nelson
,
S. A.
Gelman
, &
P. H.
Miller
(Eds.),
Conceptual development: Piaget’s legacy
(pp.
185
208
Lawrence Erlbaum
.
86.
Oyama
S.
,
Griffiths
P. E.
, &
Gray
R. D.
2001
Cycles of contingency: Developmental systems and evolution
.
MIT Press
.
87.
Rakyan
V. K.
,
Chong
S.
,
Champ
M. E.
,
Cuthbert
P. C.
,
Morgan
H. D.
,
Luu
K. V. K.
et al
2003
Transgenerational inheritance of epigenetic states at the murine AxinFu allele occurs after maternal and paternal transmission
.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA
100
5
2538
2543
.
88.
Richards
C. L.
,
Bossdorf
O.
, &
Pigliucci
M.
2010
What role does heritable epigenetic variation play in phenotypic evolution
.
BioScience
60
3
232
237
.
89.
Robert
J. S.
2004
Embryology, epigenesis, and evolution: Taking development seriously
.
Cambridge University Press
.
90.
Roth
T. L.
,
Lubin
F. D.
,
Funk
A. J.
, &
Sweatt
J. D.
2009
Lasting epigenetic influence of early-life adversity on the BDNF gene
.
Biological Psychiatry
65
9
760
769
.
91.
Russo
V. E. A.
,
Martienssen
R. A.
, &
Riggs
A. D.
1996
Epigenetic mechanisms of gene regulation
.
Cold Spring Harbor Laboratory Press
.
92.
Saunders
P. T.
2017
Epigenetics and evolution
.
Human Development
60
2-3
81
94
.
93.
Skinner
M. K.
,
Anway
M. D.
,
Savenkova
M.
,
Gore
A. C.
, &
Crews
D.
2008
Transgenerational epigenetic programming of the brain transcriptome and anxiety behavior
.
PLoS One
3
11
e345
.
94.
Uller
T.
, &
Helanterä
H.
2017
Heredity and evolutionary theory
. In
P.
Huneman
, &
D. M.
Walsh
(Eds),
Challenging the modern synthesis: Adaptation, development, and inheritance
(pp.
280
316
Oxford University Press
.
95.
Waddington
C. H.
1941
Evolution of developmental systems
.
Nature
147
3717
108
110
.
96.
Waddington
C. H.
1942
The epigenotype
.
Endeavour
1
18
20
.
97.
Waddington
C. H.
1957
The strategy of the genes
.
Allen and Unwin
.
98.
Waggoner
M. R.
, &
Uller
T.
2015
Epigenetic determinism in science and society
.
New Genetics and Society
34
2
177
195
.
99.
Walsh
D. M.
2015
Organisms, agency, and evolution
.
Cambridge University Press
.
100.
Warner
R. R.
1984
Mating behavior and hermaphroditism in coral reef fishes
.
American Scientist
72
128
136
.
101.
Wei
G. Z.
,
Martin
K. A.
,
Xing
P. Y.
,
Agrawal
R.
,
Whiley
L.
,
Wood
T. K.
,
Hejndorf
S.
,
Ng
Y. Z.
,
Low
J. Z. Y.
,
Rossant
J.
,
Nechanitzky
R.
,
Holmes
E.
,
Nicholson
J. K.
,
Tan
E. K.
,
Matthews
P. M.
, &
Pettersson
S.
2021
Tryptophan-metabolizing gut microbes regulate adult neurogenesis via the aryl hydrocarbon receptor
.
Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences USA
118
27
e2021091118
.
102.
Weismann
A.
1893
The germ plasm: A theory of heredity
.
Charles Scribner’s Sons
.
103.
West
M. J.
,
King
A. P.
, &
Freeberg
T. M.
1994
The nature and nurture of neo-phenotypes: A case history
. In
L. A.
Real
(Ed),
Behavioral mechanisms in evolutionary ecology
(pp.
238
257
University of Chicago Press
.
104.
West-Eberhard
M. J.
2003
Developmental plasticity and evolution
.
Oxford University Press
.
105.
Whimbey
A. C.
, &
Denenberg
V. H.
1967
Experimental programming of life histories: The factor structure underlying experimentally created individual differences
.
Behaviour
29
2
296
314
.
106.
Wolf
J. B.
, &
Wade
M. J.
2009
What are maternal effects (and what are they not)
.
Philosophical Transactions of the Royal Society B: Biological Sciences
364
1520
1107
1115
.
107.
Wolf
U.
1995
The genetic contribution to the phenotype
.
Human Genetics
95
2
127
148
.
You do not currently have access to this content.