Abstract
Introduction: Treatment intensity for people with aphasia (PWA) is a significant factor in enhancing recovery. Personal factors such as fatigue, physical endurance, and motivation as well as clinician availability have been described as barriers to increased intensity. The use of student therapists has been shown to assist with addressing service gaps. Methods: The aim of the study was to explore the experiences of PWA who received enhanced community-based treatment delivered by speech-language pathology (SLP) students. Enhanced community-based treatment was defined as three or more treatment sessions per week targeting communication. Semi-structured interviews were conducted with 10 PWA living in New Zealand. Interview data were analysed with reflexive thematic analysis. Results: Two themes and six sub-themes were developed. Theme 1 related to intensity and included more treatment is better than less (sub-theme 1), there’s a “right time” for more intensive treatment (sub-theme 2), the hard work is worth the effort (sub-theme 3). Theme 2 related to working with SLP students; it didn’t feel like they were students (sub-theme 4), we just got on so well (sub-theme 5), and they listened to what I wanted (sub-theme 6). Conclusions: The findings confirm that PWA value access to more intensive treatment and desire involvement in decisions about flexible treatment schedules. PWA have positive experiences when treatment is provided by SLP students. Implications for clinical practice and future research directions are discussed.
Journal Section:
Research Article
References
1.
Goodglass
H
, Kaplan
E
. The assessment of aphasia and related disorders
. 2nd ed.Philadelphia
: Lea & Ferbiger
; 1983
.2.
Davidson
B
, Howe
T
, Worrall
L
, Hickson
L
, Togher
L
. Social participation for older people with aphasia: the impact of communication disability on friendships
. Top Stroke Rehabil
. 2008
;15
(4
):325
–40
. 3.
Graham
JR
, Pereira
S
, Teasell
R
. Aphasia and return to work in younger stroke survivors
. Aphasiology
. 2011
;25
(8
):952
–60
. 4.
Worrall
L
, Ryan
B
, Hudson
K
, Kneebone
I
, Simmons-Mackie
N
, Khan
A
, et al. Reducing the psychosocial impact of aphasia on mood and quality of life in people with aphasia and the impact of caregiving in family members through the Aphasia Action Success Knowledge (Aphasia ASK) program: study protocol for a randomized controlled trial
. Trials
. 2016
;17
(1
):153
. 5.
Brady
MC
. Dosage, intensity, and frequency of language therapy for aphasia: a systematic review-based, individual participant data Network meta-analysis
. Stroke
. 2022
;29
(2
).6.
Godecke
E
, Armstrong
E
, Rai
T
, Ciccone
N
, Rose
ML
, Middleton
S
, et al. A randomized control trial of intensive aphasia therapy after acute stroke: the Very Early Rehabilitation for SpEech (VERSE) study
. Int J Stroke
. 2021
;16
(5
):556
–72
. 7.
Pierce
JE
, O’Halloran
R
, Menahemi-Falkov
M
, Togher
L
, Rose
ML
. Comparing higher and lower weekly treatment intensity for chronic aphasia: a systematic review and meta-analysis
. Neuropsychol Rehabil
. 2021
;31
(8
):1289
–313
. 8.
Rose
M
, Ferguson
A
, Power
E
, Togher
L
, Worrall
L
. Aphasia rehabilitation in Australia: current practices, challenges and future directions
. Int J Speech Lang Pathol
. 2014
;16
(2
):169
–80
. 9.
Stahl
B
, Mohr
B
, Büscher
V
, Dreyer
FR
, Lucchese
G
, Pulvermüller
F
. Efficacy of intensive aphasia therapy in patients with chronic stroke: a randomised controlled trial
. J Neurol Neurosurg Psychiatry
. 2018
;89
(6
):586
–92
. 10.
Roth
FP
, Worthington
CK
. Treatment resource manual for speech-language pathology
. 6th ed. [Place unknown]: ProQuest Ebook Central: Plural Publishing
; 2019
.11.
Husak
RS
, Wallace
SE
, Marshall
RC
, Visch-Brink
EG
. A systematic review of aphasia therapy provided in the early period of post-stroke recovery
. Aphasiology
. 2021
;37
(1
):143
–76
. 12.
Cherney
LR
, Patterson
JP
, Raymer
AM
. Intensity of aphasia therapy: evidence and efficacy
. Curr Neurol Neurosci Rep
. 2011
;11
(6
):560
–9
. 13.
Cherney
LR
, Patterson
JP
, Raymer
A
, Frymark
T
, Schooling
T
. Evidence-based systematic review: effects of intensity of treatment and constraint-induced language therapy for individuals with stroke-induced aphasia
. J Speech Lang Hear Res
. 2008
;51
(5
):1282
–99
. 14.
Dignam
J
, Copland
D
, McKinnon
E
, Burfein
P
, O’Brien
K
, Farrell
A
, et al. Intensive versus distributed aphasia therapy: a nonrandomized, parallel-group, dosage-controlled study
. Stroke
. 2015
;46
(8
):2206
–11
. 15.
Guo
YE
, Togher
L
, Power
E
. Speech pathology services for people with aphasia: what is the current practice in Singapore
. Disabil Rehabil
. 2014
;36
(8
):691
–704
. 16.
Yeo
J
, Zhou
L
, Ratnasabapthy
Y
. Stroke care delivery at north shore hospital, waitemata district health board 2014
. N Z Med J
. 2016
;129
(1431
):67
–79
.17.
Palmer
R
, Dimairo
M
, Cooper
C
, Enderby
P
, Brady
M
, Bowen
A
, et al. Self-managed, computerised speech and language therapy for patients with chronic aphasia post-stroke compared with usual care or attention control (Big CACTUS): a multicentre, single-blinded, randomised controlled trial
. Lancet Neurol
. 2019
;18
(9
):821
–33
. 18.
Bhogal
SK
, Teasell
R
, Speechley
M
. Intensity of aphasia therapy, impact on recovery
. Stroke
. 2003
;34
(4
):987
–93
. 19.
Code
C
, Heron
C
. Services for aphasia, other acquired adult neurogenic communication and swallowing disorders in the United Kingdom, 2000
. Disabil Rehabil
. 2003
;25
(21
):1231
–7
. 20.
Kurland
J
, Baldwin
K
, Tauer
C
. Treatment-induced neuroplasticity following intensive naming therapy in a case of chronic wernicke’s aphasia
. Aphasiology
. 2010
;24
(6–8
):737
–51
. 21.
Schindel
D
, Mandl
L
, Schilling
R
, Meisel
A
, Schenk
L
. Guideline adherence in speech and language therapy in stroke aftercare. A health insurance claims data analysis
. PLoS One
. 2022
;17
(2
):e0263397
. 22.
Verna
A
, Davidson
B
, Rose
T
. Speech-language pathology services for people with aphasia: a survey of current practice in Australia
. Int J Speech Lang Pathol
. 2009
;11
(3
):191
–205
. 23.
Gunning
D
, Wenke
R
, Ward
EC
, Chalk
S
, Lawrie
M
, Romano
M
, et al. Clinicians’ perceptions of delivering new models of high intensity aphasia treatment
. Aphasiology
. 2017
;31
(4
):406
–26
. 24.
Janssen
J
, Klassen
TD
, Connell
LA
, Eng
JJ
. Factors influencing the delivery of intensive rehabilitation in stroke: patient perceptions versus rehabilitation therapist perceptions
. Phys Ther
. 2020
;100
(2
):307
–16
. 25.
Shrubsole
K
, Worrall
L
, Power
E
, O’Connor
DA
. Barriers and facilitators to meeting aphasia guideline recommendations: what factors influence speech pathologists’ practice
. Disabil Rehabil
. 2019
;41
(13
):1596
–607
. 26.
Monnelly
K
, Marshall
J
, Cruice
M
. Intensive Comprehensive Aphasia Programmes: a systematic scoping review and analysis using the TIDieR checklist for reporting interventions
. Disabil Rehabil
. 2022
;44
(21
):6471
–96
. 27.
Leff
AP
, Nightingale
S
, Gooding
B
, Rutter
J
, Craven
N
, Peart
M
, et al. Clinical effectiveness of the queen square intensive comprehensive aphasia service for patients with poststroke aphasia
. Stroke
. 2021
;52
(10
):594
–8
. 28.
Rose
M
, Cherney
L
, Worrall
L
. Intensive comprehensive aphasia programs: an international survey of practice
. Top Stroke Rehabil
. 2013
;20
(5
):379
–87
. 29.
Worrall
L
, Sherratt
S
, Rogers
P
, Howe
T
, Hersh
D
, Ferguson
A
, et al. What people with aphasia want: their goals according to the ICF
. Aphasiology
. 2011
;25
(3
):309
–22
. 30.
Bourne
E
, McAllister
L
, Nagarajan
S
, Short
K
. The effect of speech-language pathology students on clinician time use and activity
. Int J Speech Lang Pathol
. 2019
;21
(2
):163
–74
. 31.
Sokkar
C
, Penman
M
, Raymond
J
, McAllister
L
. An evaluation of client satisfaction with student-delivered speech-language pathology services in private practice
. J Clin Pract Speech-Language Pathol
. 2019
;21
(2
):65
–9
. 32.
Vilapakkam Nagarajan
S
, Nicole
M
, Fairbrother
M
, Blackford
J
, McAllister
L
. Student-led clinics: building placement capacity and filling service gaps
. ACEN 2014 national conference work integrated learning: building capacity
. 2014
.33.
Lawrence
D
, Bryant
TK
, Nobel
TB
, Dolansky
MA
, Singh
MK
. A comparative evaluation of patient satisfaction outcomes in an interprofessional student-run free clinic
. J Interprof Care
. 2015
;29
(5
):445
–50
. 34.
Forbes
DR
, Nolan
D
. Factors associated with patient-satisfaction in student-led physiotherapy clinics: a qualitative study
. Physiother Theory Pract
. 2018
;34
(9
):705
–13
. 35.
Asanad
K
, Zheng
J
, Chan-Golston
A
, Tam
E
, Bhetraratana
M
, Lan
CW
, et al. Assessing quality of care through client satisfaction at an interprofessional student-run free clinic
. J Interprof Care
. 2018
;32
(2
):203
–10
. 36.
Auclair-Ouellet
N
, Tittley
L
, Root
K
. Effect of an intensive comprehensive aphasia program on language and communication in chronic aphasia
. Aphasiology
. 2022
;36
(11
):1312
–32
. 37.
Griffin-Musick
JR
, Jakober
D
, Sallay
A
, Milman
L
, Off
CA
. Cognitive-linguistic outcomes from an intensive comprehensive aphasia program implemented by graduate student clinicians
. Aphasiology
. 2022
;36
(9
):1015
–29
. 38.
Off
CA
, Leyhe
AA
, Baylor
CR
, Griffin-Musick
J
, Murray
K
. Patient perspectives of a university-based intensive comprehensive aphasia program for stroke survivors with aphasia
. Aphasiology
. 2022
;38
(1
):22
–49
. 39.
Jones
D
, McAllister
L
, Lyle
D
. Stepping out of the shadows: allied health student and academic perceptions of the impact of a service-learning experience on student’s work-readiness and employability
. J Teach Learn Graduate Employability
. 2015
;6
(1
):66
–87
. 40.
O’Brien
A
, McNeil
K
, Dawson
A
. The student experience of clinical supervision across health disciplines: perspectives and remedies to enhance clinical placement
. Nurse Educ Pract
. 2019
;34
:48
–55
. 41.
Rodger
S
, Webb
G
, Devitt
L
, Gilbert
J
, Wrightson
P
, McMeeken
J
. A clinical education and practice placements in the allied health professions: an international perspective
. J Allied Health
. 2008
;37
(1
):53
–62
.42.
Speech Pathology Australia
. Position Statement: Clinical Education – the importance and value for the speech pathology profession
. 2005
. https://speechpathologyaustralia.org.au/library/position_statements/Clinical_Education.pft43.
Lincoln
M
, Adamson
B
, Covic
T
. Perceptions of stress, time management and coping strategies of speech pathology students on clinical placement
. Int J Speech Lang Pathol
. 2004
;6
(2
):91
–9
. 44.
Quail
M
, Brundage
SB
, Spitalnick
J
, Allen
PJ
, Beilby
J
. Student self-reported communication skills, knowledge and confidence across standardised patient, virtual and traditional clinical learning environments
. BMC Med Educ
. 2016
;16
(1
):73
. 45.
McAllister
S
, Lincoln
M
, Ferguson
A
, McAllister
L
. A systematic program of research regarding the assessment of speech-language pathology competencies
. Int J Speech Lang Pathol
. 2011
;13
(6
):469
–79
. 46.
Attrill
S
, Gunn
S
. Clients becoming teachers: speech-language pathology students’ understanding of rehabilitation following clinical practicum in a rehabilitation setting
. Int J Speech Lang Pathol
. 2010
;12
(2
):142
–51
. 47.
Parker
A
, Emanuel
R
. Active learning in service delivery: an approach to initial clinical placements
. Int J Lang Commun Disord
. 2001
;36
(Suppl
):162
–6
. 48.
Sheepway
L
, Lincoln
M
, McAllister
S
. Impact of placement type on the development of clinical competency in speech-language pathology students
. Int J Lang Commun Disord
. 2014
;49
(2
):189
–203
. 49.
NZ National Stroke Network
. Minimum ministry of health expectations to meet designation of “community stroke rehabilitation service”
. New Zealand
; 2017
.50.
Threats
TT
. The ICF and speech-language pathology: aspiring to a fuller realization of ethical and moral issues
. Int J Speech Lang Pathol
. 2010
;12
(2
):87
–93
. 51.
te Kāwanatanga te Aotearoa. Govt.nz
. Enduring Power of Attorney (EPA) for personal care and welfare
. 2021
.52.
Kagan
A
. Revealing the competence of aphasic adults through conversation: a challenge to health professionals
. Top Stroke Rehabil
. 1995
;2
(1
):15
–28
. 53.
Luck
AM
, Rose
ML
. Interviewing people with aphasia: insights into method adjustments from a pilot study
. Aphasiology
. 2007
;21
(2
):208
–24
. 54.
Johansson
MB
, Carlsson
M
, Sonnander
K
. Communication difficulties and the use of communication strategies: from the perspective of individuals with aphasia
. Int J Lang Commun Disord
. 2012
;47
(2
):144
–55
. 55.
Wilson
C
, Kim
ES
. Qualitative data collection: considerations for people with Aphasia
. Aphasiology
. 2021
;35
(3
):314
–33
. 56.
Braun
V
, Clarke
V
. Reflecting on reflexive thematic analysis
. Qual Res Sport Exerc Health
. 2019
;11
(4
):589
–97
. 57.
Braun
V
, Clarke
V
. Using thematic analysis in psychology
. Qual Res Psychol
. 2006
;3
(2
):77
–101
. 58.
Braun
V
, Clarke
V
. Successful qualitative research: a practical guide for beginners
. SAGE Publications Ltd
; 2013
.59.
Madill
A
, Jordan
A
, Shirley
C
. Objectivity and reliability in qualitative analysis: realist, contextualist and radical constructionist epistemologies
. Br J Psychol
. 2000
;91(Pt 1)
(1
):1
–20
. 60.
Creswell
JW
. Qualitative inquiry and research design choosing among five traditions
. Thousand Oaks (CA)
: Sage Publications
; 2007
.61.
QSR International Pty Ltd
. NVivo [Internet]
. [no location]: QSR International Pty Ltd
; 2020
[cited 2022 Sep 12]. Available from: https://www.qsrinternational.com/nvivo-qualitative-data-analysis-software/home62.
Guest
G
, Namey
E
, Chen
M
. A simple method to assess and report thematic saturation in qualitative research
. PLoS One
. 2020
;15
(5
):e0232076
. 63.
Brady
M
, Enderby
P
, Kelly
H
, Godwin
J
, Campbell
P
. Speech and Language Therapy (SLT) for aphasia after stroke: cochrane systematic review evidence of therapy regimens, delivery models and theoretical approaches
. Eur Stroke J
. 2016
;1
(1
).64.
Bakheit
AMO
, Shaw
S
, Barrett
L
, Wood
J
, Carrington
S
, Griffiths
S
, et al. A prospective, randomized, parallel group, controlled study of the effect of intensity of speech and language therapy on early recovery from poststroke aphasia
. Clin Rehabil
. 2007
;21
(10
):885
–94
. © 2024 S. Karger AG, Basel
Copyright / Drug Dosage / Disclaimer
Copyright: All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be translated into other languages, reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, microcopying, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Drug Dosage: The authors and the publisher have exerted every effort to ensure that drug selection and dosage set forth in this text are in accord with current recommendations and practice at the time of publication. However, in view of ongoing research, changes in government regulations, and the constant flow of information relating to drug therapy and drug reactions, the reader is urged to check the package insert for each drug for any changes in indications and dosage and for added warnings and precautions. This is particularly important when the recommended agent is a new and/or infrequently employed drug.
Disclaimer: The statements, opinions and data contained in this publication are solely those of the individual authors and contributors and not of the publishers and the editor(s). The appearance of advertisements or/and product references in the publication is not a warranty, endorsement, or approval of the products or services advertised or of their effectiveness, quality or safety. The publisher and the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to persons or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content or advertisements.
2024
You do not currently have access to this content.
