Introduction: Chronic pancreatitis (CP) is characterised by pain, functional deficits, nutritional and mechanical complications. Frequently managed in out-patient settings, the clinical course is unpredictable and requires multi-disciplinary care. There remains substantial variation in management. In contrast to acute pancreatitis, there are no globally accepted classification or severity scores to predict the disease course or compare interventions. We conducted a systematic review to determine the scope and clinical use of existing scoring systems. Methods: A systematic search was developed with a medical librarian using the Embase, Medline and Cochrane databases. Original articles and conference abstracts describing an original or modified classification or scoring system in CP that stratified patients into clinical and/or severity categories were included. To assess clinical application/validation, studies using all or part of a score as a stratification tool to measure another parameter or outcome were selected. Studies reporting on diagnosis or aetiology only were excluded. Four authors performed the search in independent pairs and conflicts were resolved by a fifth author using CovidenceTM systematic review software. Results: Following screening 6,652 titles and 235 full-text reviews, 48 papers were analysed. Eleven described original scores and 6 described modifications of published scores. Many were comprehensive but limited in capturing the full spectrum of disease. In 31 studies, a score was used to categorise patients to compare or correlate various outcome measures. Exocrine and endocrine dysfunction and pain were included in 6, 5, and 4 scoring systems, respectively. No score included other nutrition parameters, such as bone health, malnutrition, or nutrient deficiency. Only one score has been objectively validated prospectively and independently for monitoring clinical progression and prognosis, but this had been applied to an in-patient population. Conclusion: Available systems and scores do not reflect recent advances and guidelines in CP and are not commonly used. A practical clinical classification and scoring system, validated prospectively for prognostication would be useful for the meaningful analysis in observational and interventional studies in CP.

Keywords:
Chronic pancreatitis, Severity score, Clinical classification
1.
DiMagno MJ, Dimagno EP. Chronic pancreatitis.
Curr Opin Gastroenterol
. 2006 Sep;22(5):487–97.
2.
Uomo G. How far are we from the most accurate classification system for chronic pancreatitis?
JOP
. 2002 May;3(3):62–5.
3.
Lankisch PG, Löhr-Happe A, Otto J, Creutzfeldt W. Natural course in chronic pancreatitis. Pain, exocrine and endocrine pancreatic insufficiency and prognosis of the disease.
Digestion
. 1993;54(3):148–55.
4.
Layer P, Yamamoto H, Kalthoff L, Clain JE, Bakken LJ, DiMagno EP. The different courses of early- and late-onset idiopathic and alcoholic chronic pancreatitis.
Gastroenterology
. 1994 Nov;107(5):1481–7.
5.
Ammann RW, Muellhaupt B; Zurich Pancreatitis Study Group. The natural history of pain in alcoholic chronic pancreatitis.
Gastroenterology
. 1999 May;116(5):1132–40.
6.
Dominguez-Munoz JE, Drewes AM, Lindkvist B, Ewald N, Czakó L, Rosendahl J, et al.; HaPanEU/UEG Working Group. Recommendations from the United European Gastroenterology evidence-based guidelines for the diagnosis and therapy of chronic pancreatitis.
Pancreatology
. 2018 Dec;18(8):847–54.
7.
Majumder S, Chari ST. Chronic pancreatitis.
Lancet
. 2016 May;387(10031):1957–66.
8.
Joergensen M, Brusgaard K, Crüger DG, Gerdes AM, de Muckadell OB. Incidence, prevalence, etiology, and prognosis of first-time chronic pancreatitis in young patients: a nationwide cohort study.
Dig Dis Sci
. 2010 Oct;55(10):2988–98.
9.
Schneider A, Löhr JM, Singer MV. The M-ANNHEIM classification of chronic pancreatitis: introduction of a unifying classification system based on a review of previous classifications of the disease.
J Gastroenterol
. 2007 Feb;42(2):101–19.
10.
Sarner M, Cotton PB. Classification of pancreatitis.
Gut
. 1984 Jul;25(7):756–9.
11.
Catalano MF, Sahai A, Levy M, Romagnuolo J, Wiersema M, Brugge W, et al. EUS-based criteria for the diagnosis of chronic pancreatitis: the Rosemont classification.
Gastrointest Endosc
. 2009 Jun;69(7):1251–61.
12.
Etemad B, Whitcomb DC. Chronic pancreatitis: diagnosis, classification, and new genetic developments.
Gastroenterology
. 2001 Feb;120(3):682–707.
13.
Gupte A, Goede D, Tuite R, Forsmark CE. Chronic pancreatitis.
BMJ
. 2018 Jun;361:k2126.
14.
Büchler MW, Martignoni ME, Friess H, Malfertheiner P. A proposal for a new clinical classification of chronic pancreatitis.
BMC Gastroenterol
. 2009 Dec;9(1):93.
15.
Stern I, Roberts-Thomson IC, Hansky J. Correlation between pancreatic polypeptide response to secretin and ERCP findings in chronic pancreatitis.
Gut
. 1982 Mar;23(3):235–8.
16.
Catalano MF, Lahoti S, Geenen JE, Hogan WJ. Prospective evaluation of endoscopic ultrasonography, endoscopic retrograde pancreatography, and secretin test in the diagnosis of chronic pancreatitis.
Gastrointest Endosc
. 1998 Jul;48(1):11–7.
17.
Gullo L, Ventrucci M, Tomassetti P, Migliori M, Pezzilli R. Fecal elastase 1 determination in chronic pancreatitis.
Dig Dis Sci
. 1999 Jan;44(1):210–3.
18.
Ramesh H. Proposal for a new grading system for chronic pancreatitis: the ABC system.
J Clin Gastroenterol
. 2002 Jul;35(1):67–70.
19.
Bagul A, Siriwardena AK. Evaluation of the Manchester classification system for chronic pancreatitis.
JOP
. 2006 Jul;7(4):390–6.
20.
Orlikov GA, Pliavinia IA, Pokrotnieks IIa, Seleznev IV. [Ultrasonographic assessment of chronic pancreatitis severity. Pancreatic index].
Ter Arkh
. 2007;79(2):48–51.
21.
Naniwadekar A, Ellis R, Gennings C, Sanyal A, Vachhani R, BouHaidar D, et al. CP Severity Index: A reliable scoring system to assess severity and progression of chronic pancreatitis.
Gastoenterol
. 2011;140(5):S-545.
22.
He D, Matthews S, Kalloo A, Hutfless S. Mining high-dimensional administrative claims data to predict early hospital readmissions.
J Am Med Inform Assoc
. 2014 Mar-Apr;21(2):272-9.
23.
Beyer G, Mahajan UM, Budde C, Bulla TJ, Kohlmann T, Kuhlmann L, et al. Development and Validation of a Chronic Pancreatitis Prognosis Score in 2 Independent Cohorts.
Gastroenterology
. 2017 Dec;153(6):1544–1554.e2.
24.
Jones SN, Lees WR, Frost RA. Diagnosis and grading of chronic pancreatitis by morphological criteria derived by ultrasound and pancreatography.
Clin Radiol
. 1988 Jan;39(1):43–8.
25.
Bozkurt T, Braun U, Leferink S, Gilly G, Lux G. Comparison of pancreatic morphology and exocrine functional impairment in patients with chronic pancreatitis.
Gut
. 1994 Aug;35(8):1132–6.
26.
Yasuda M, Ito T, Oono T, Kawabe K, Kaku T, Igarashi H, et al. Fractalkine and TGF-β1 levels reflect the severity of chronic pancreatitis in humans.
World J Gastroenterol
. 2008 Nov;14(42):6488–95.
27.
Akisik MF, Aisen AM, Sandrasegaran K, Jennings SG, Lin C, Sherman S, et al. Assessment of chronic pancreatitis: utility of diffusion-weighted MR imaging with secretin enhancement.
Radiology
. 2009 Jan;250(1):103–9.
28.
Stevens T, Berk MP, Lopez R, Chung YM, Zhang R, Parsi MA, et al. Lipidomic profiling of serum and pancreatic fluid in chronic pancreatitis.
Pancreas
. 2012 May;41(4):518–22.
29.
Bahuva R, Walsh RM, Kapural L, Stevens T. Morphologic abnormalities are poorly predictive of visceral pain in chronic pancreatitis.
Pancreas
. 2013 Jan;42(1):6–10.
30.
Itoh H, Shimono R, Hamamoto K. Evaluation of common bile duct stenosis in chronic pancreatitis using cholescintigraphy.
Eur J Nucl Med
. 1988;14(3):137–40.
31.
Nagai K, Iguchi K, Yanaihara N. Plasma lipase, C-peptide reactivity and human pancreatic polypeptide responses after ingestion of elemental diet in patients with chronic pancreatitis.
Gastroenterol Jpn
. 1993 Jun;28(3):401–5.
32.
von Tirpitz C, Glasbrenner B, Mayer D, Malfertheiner P, Adler G. Comparison of different endocrine stimulation tests in nondiabetic patients with chronic pancreatitis.
Hepatogastroenterology
. 1998 Jul-Aug;45(22):1111–6.
33.
Al-Eryani S, Duris I, Huorka M, Payer J, Kratochvilova H, Ondrejka P. Plasma gastrin levels in alcoholic and idiopathic chronic pancreatitis patients free from Helicobacter pylori infection.
Ann Saudi Med
. 2001 Jan-Mar;21(1-2):9–12.
34.
Mann ST, Stracke H, Lange U, Klör HU, Teichmann J. Alterations of bone mineral density and bone metabolism in patients with various grades of chronic pancreatitis.
Metabolism
. 2003 May;52(5):579–85.
35.
Maartense S, Ledeboer M, Masclee AA. Chronic pancreatitis: relation between function and morphology.
Dig Liver Dis
. 2004 Jan;36(1):61–7.
36.
Sandhu BS, Hackworth WA, Stevens S, Bouhaidar DS, Zfass AM, Sanyal AJ. Recurrent flares of pancreatitis predict development of exocrine insufficiency in chronic pancreatitis.
Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol
. 2007 Sep;5(9):1085–91.
37.
Teichmann J, Mann ST, Stracke H, Lange U, Hardt PD, Klör HU, et al. Alterations of vitamin D3 metabolism in young women with various grades of chronic pancreatitis.
Eur J Med Res
. 2007 Aug;12(8):347–50.
38.
Bilgin M, Bilgin S, Balci NC, Momtahen AJ, Bilgin Y, Klör HU, et al. Magnetic resonance imaging and magnetic resonance cholangiopancreatography findings compared with fecal elastase 1 measurement for the diagnosis of chronic pancreatitis.
Pancreas
. 2008 Jan;36(1):e33–9.
39.
Stevens T, Conwell DL, Zuccaro G Jr, Vargo JJ, Dumot JA, Lopez R. Comparison of endoscopic ultrasound and endoscopic retrograde pancreatography for the prediction of pancreatic exocrine insufficiency.
Dig Dis Sci
. 2008 Apr;53(4):1146–51.
40.
Akisik MF, Sandrasegaran K, Jennings SG, Aisen AM, Lin C, Sherman S, et al. Diagnosis of chronic pancreatitis by using apparent diffusion coefficient measurements at 3.0-T MR following secretin stimulation.
Radiology
. 2009 Aug;252(2):418–25.
41.
Usküdar O, Oğuz D, Akdoğan M, Altiparmak E, Şahin B. Comparison of endoscopic retrograde cholangiopancreatography, endoscopic ultrasonography, and fecal elastase 1 in chronic pancreatitis and clinical correlation.
Pancreas
. 2009 Jul;38(5):503–6.
42.
Bilgin M, Balci NC, Momtahen AJ, Bilgin Y, Klör HU, Rau WS. MRI and MRCP findings of the pancreas in patients with diabetes mellitus: compared analysis with pancreatic exocrine function determined by fecal elastase 1.
J Clin Gastroenterol
. 2009 Feb;43(2):165–70.
43.
Balci NC, Smith A, Momtahen AJ, Alkaade S, Fattahi R, Tariq S, et al. MRI and S-MRCP findings in patients with suspected chronic pancreatitis: correlation with endoscopic pancreatic function testing (ePFT).
J Magn Reson Imaging
. 2010 Mar;31(3):601–6.
44.
Hawkins P, Balci N, Burton F, Alkaade S, Choueiri N, Forrest S, et al. M1378 Progressive Changes of Altered Perfusion by Fast 3D Dynamic Contrast-Enhanced MR Imaging Pre- And Post-Secretin Seen With Increasing Changes of Chronic Pancreatitis on MRCP.
Gastroenterology
. 2010;138(5):S-392.
45.
Singer M, Maissonneuve P, Loehr M, Schneider A. Proposal of a New Classification System of Chronic Pancreatitis.
Pancreatology
. 2010;10(S1):16.
46.
Takita M, Naziruddin B, Matsumoto S, Noguchi H, Shimoda M, Chujo D, et al. Implication of pancreatic image findings in total pancreatectomy with islet autotransplantation for chronic pancreatitis.
Pancreas
. 2011 Jan;40(1):103–8.
47.
Katsotourchi A, Frulloni L, Amodio A, Viaro T, Tumelero T, Pellicciari M, et al. Evaluation of M-ANNHEIM classification in an Italian series of patients suffering from chronic pancreatitis.
Dig Liver Dis
. 2011;43(S3):S144.
48.
Kadiyala V, Banks P, Lee L, Rosenblum J, Paulo J, Sainani N et al. Cigarette smoking impacts chronic pancreatitis clinical feature score, severity index and imaging severity. Am J Gastroenterol. 2011;106(S2):S59-60.
49.
Bouwense SA, Olesen SS, Drewes AM, Frøkjær JB, van Goor H, Wilder-Smith OH. Is altered central pain processing related to disease stage in chronic pancreatitis patients with pain? An exploratory study.
PLoS One
. 2013;8(2):e55460.
50.
Bian Y, Wang L, Chen C, Lu JP, Fan JB, Chen SY, et al. Quantification of pancreatic exocrine function of chronic pancreatitis with secretin-enhanced MRCP.
World J Gastroenterol
. 2013 Nov;19(41):7177–82.
51.
Burton S, Kadiyala V, Suleiman S, Lee L, Banks P, Conwell D. Validation of M-ANNHEIM imaging grade for use with MRI/MRCP in chronic pancreatitis.
Pancreatology
. 2013;13(2):e8.
52.
Fernández Cano F, Romero Ordóñez M, González Bárcenas M, Rivera Irigoin R, López Vega M, Rosales Zábal J, et al. Do endoscopic ultrasound provides information in evaluating exocrine pancreatic insufficiency in chronic pancreatitis? Pancreatology. 2013;13(4 S1):e16.
53.
Härteol N, Weiss C, Ebert M, Schneider A. Comparison of the clinical parameters of the m-annheim classification system in patients with alcoholic and non-alcoholic chronic pancreatitis. Pancreatology. 2014;14(3S1):S40–1.
54.
He YX, Xu HW, Sun XT, Ye Z, Wang W, Lai XW, et al. Endoscopic management of early-stage chronic pancreatitis based on M-ANNHEIM classification system: a prospective study.
Pancreas
. 2014 Aug;43(6):829–33.
55.
Hirth M, Kolb S, Weiß C, Rückert F, Wilhelm T, Hardt P, et al. Who needs to be operated? Prognostic evaluation of the necessity of surgery in chronic pancreatitis according to the M-ANNHEIM classification.
Pancreatology
. 2015;15(3):S71.
56.
Peixoto A, Silva M, Boas F, Rodrigues-Pinto E, Pereira P, Macedo G. Concordance between imaging and functional studies in the diagnosis of pancreatic exocrine insufficiency.
Pancreatology
. 2015;15(3):S80.
57.
Gecov P, Siminkovitch S, Vladimirov B, Nedelkov G, Kovacheva-Slavova G, Golemanov B. Evaluation of secretin-enhanced MRCP in chronic pancreatitis.
Pancreas
. 2016;45(10):1506.
58.
Fujiyama T, Ito T, Ueda K, Tachibana Y, Yasunaga K, Miki M, et al. Serum levels of Wisteria floribunda agglutinin-positive Mac-2 binding protein reflect the severity of chronic pancreatitis.
J Dig Dis
. 2017 May;18(5):302–8.
59.
Zhao ZH, Hu LH, Ren HB, Zhao AJ, Qian YY, Sun XT, et al. Incidence and risk factors for post-ERCP pancreatitis in chronic pancreatitis.
Gastrointest Endosc
. 2017 Sep;86(3):519–524.e1.
60.
Madzak A, Olesen SS, Haldorsen IS, Drewes AM, Frøkjær JB. Secretin-stimulated MRI characterization of pancreatic morphology and function in patients with chronic pancreatitis.
Pancreatology
. 2017 Mar - Apr;17(2):228–36.
61.
Blamey SL, Imrie CW, O’Neill J, Gilmour WH, Carter DC. Prognostic factors in acute pancreatitis.
Gut
. 1984 Dec;25(12):1340–6.
62.
Ranson JH, Rifkind KM, Turner JW. Prognostic signs and nonoperative peritoneal lavage in acute pancreatitis.
Surg Gynecol Obstet
. 1976 Aug;143(2):209–19.
63.
Jairath V, Zou G, Parker CE, Macdonald JK, Mosli MH, Khanna R, et al. Systematic review and meta-analysis: placebo rates in induction and maintenance trials of ulcerative colitis.
J Crohn’s Colitis
. 2016 May;10(5):607–18.
64.
Wilcox CM, Yadav D, Ye T, Gardner TB, Gelrud A, Sandhu BS, et al. Chronic pancreatitis pain pattern and severity are independent of abdominal imaging findings.
Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol
. 2015 Mar;13(3):552–60.
65.
Duggan SN, Ní Chonchubhair HM, Lawal O, O’Connor DB, Conlon KC. Chronic pancreatitis: A diagnostic dilemma.
World J Gastroenterol
. 2016 Feb;22(7):2304–13.
66.
Hollemans RA, Hallensleben ND, Mager DJ, Kelder JC, Besselink MG, Bruno MJ, et al.; Dutch Pancreatitis Study Group. Pancreatic exocrine insufficiency following acute pancreatitis: systematic review and study level meta-analysis.
Pancreatology
. 2018 Apr;18(3):253–62.
67.
Duggan SN, Smyth ND, Murphy A, Macnaughton D, O’Keefe SJ, Conlon KC. High prevalence of osteoporosis in patients with chronic pancreatitis: a systematic review and meta-analysis.
Clin Gastroenterol Hepatol
. 2014 Feb;12(2):219–28.
68.
Duggan SN, Ewald N, Kelleher L, Griffin O, Gibney J, Conlon KC. The nutritional management of type 3c (pancreatogenic) diabetes in chronic pancreatitis.
Eur J Clin Nutr
. 2017 Jan;71(1):3–8.
69.
Ammann RW, Akovbiantz A, Largiader F, Schueler G. Course and outcome of chronic pancreatitis. Longitudinal study of a mixed medical-surgical series of 245 patients.
Gastroenterology
. 1984 May;86(5 Pt 1):820–8.
70.
Nealon WH, Matin S. Analysis of surgical success in preventing recurrent acute exacerbations in chronic pancreatitis.
Ann Surg
. 2001 Jun;233(6):793–800.
71.
Ahmed Ali U, Issa Y, Bruno MJ, van Goor H, van Santvoort H, Busch OR, et al.; Dutch Pancreatitis Study Group. Early surgery versus optimal current step-up practice for chronic pancreatitis (ESCAPE): design and rationale of a randomized trial.
BMC Gastroenterol
. 2013 Mar;13(1):49.
72.
Diener MK, Hüttner FJ, Kieser M, Knebel P, Dörr-Harim C, Distler M, et al.; ChroPac Trial Group. Partial pancreatoduodenectomy versus duodenum-preserving pancreatic head resection in chronic pancreatitis: the multicentre, randomised, controlled, double-blind ChroPac trial.
Lancet
. 2017 Sep;390(10099):1027–37.
73.
Whitcomb DC, Frulloni L, Garg P, Greer JB, Schneider A, Yadav D, et al. Chronic pancreatitis: an international draft consensus proposal for a new mechanistic definition.
Pancreatology
. 2016 Mar-Apr;16(2):218–24.
© 2019 S. Karger AG, Basel
2019
Copyright / Drug Dosage / Disclaimer
Copyright: All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be translated into other languages, reproduced or utilized in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopying, recording, microcopying, or by any information storage and retrieval system, without permission in writing from the publisher.
Drug Dosage: The authors and the publisher have exerted every effort to ensure that drug selection and dosage set forth in this text are in accord with current recommendations and practice at the time of publication. However, in view of ongoing research, changes in government regulations, and the constant flow of information relating to drug therapy and drug reactions, the reader is urged to check the package insert for each drug for any changes in indications and dosage and for added warnings and precautions. This is particularly important when the recommended agent is a new and/or infrequently employed drug.
Disclaimer: The statements, opinions and data contained in this publication are solely those of the individual authors and contributors and not of the publishers and the editor(s). The appearance of advertisements or/and product references in the publication is not a warranty, endorsement, or approval of the products or services advertised or of their effectiveness, quality or safety. The publisher and the editor(s) disclaim responsibility for any injury to persons or property resulting from any ideas, methods, instructions or products referred to in the content or advertisements.
You do not currently have access to this content.