As species change through evolutionary time, the neurological and morphological structures that underlie behavioral systems typically remain coordinated. This is especially important for communication systems, in which these structures must remain coordinated both within and between senders and receivers for successful information transfer. The acoustic communication of anurans (“frogs”) offers an excellent system to ask when and how such coordination is maintained, and to allow researchers to dissociate allometric effects from independent correlated evolution. Anurans constitute one of the most speciose groups of vocalizing vertebrates, and females typically rely on vocalizations to localize males for reproduction. Here, we compile and compare data on various aspects of auditory morphology, hearing sensitivity, and call-dominant frequency across 81 species of anurans. We find robust, phylogenetically independent scaling effects of body size for all features measured. Furthermore, after accounting for body size, we find preliminary evidence that morphological evolution beyond allometry can correlate with hearing sensitivity and dominant frequency. These data provide foundational results regarding constraints imposed by body size on communication systems and motivate further data collection and analysis using comparative approaches across the numerous anuran species.

1.
Baugh
AT
,
Bee
MA
,
Gall
MD
.
The paradox of hearing at the lek: auditory sensitivity increases after breeding in female gray treefrogs (Hyla chrysoscelis)
.
J Comp Physiol A Neuroethol Sens Neural Behav Physiol
.
2019 Aug 21
;
205
(
4
):
629
39
.
2.
Beckers
OM
,
Schul
J
.
Phonotaxis in Hyla versicolor (Anura, Hylidae): the effect of absolute call amplitude
.
J Comp Physiol A Neuroethol Sens Neural Behav Physiol
.
2004
;
190
(
11
):
869
76
.
3.
Bee
MA
,
Schwartz
JJ
.
Behavioral measures of signal recognition thresholds in frogs in the presence and absence of chorus-shaped noise
.
J Acoust Soc Am
.
2009
;
126
(
5
):
2788
801
.
4.
Bohn
KM
,
Moss
CF
,
Wilkinson
GS
.
Correlated evolution between hearing sensitivity and social calls in bats
.
Biol Lett
.
2006 Dec 22
;
2
(
4
):
561
4
.
5.
Bosch
J
,
Wilczynski
W
.
Auditory tuning of the Iberian midwife toad, Alytes cisternasii
.
Herpetol J
.
2003
;
13
(
2
):
53
7
.
6.
Bowling
DL
,
Garcia
M
,
Dunn
JC
,
Ruprecht
R
,
Stewart
A
,
Frommolt
KH
,
.
Body size and vocalization in primates and carnivores
.
Sci Rep
.
2017 Jan 24
;
7
(
1
):
41070
.
7.
Bradbury
JW
,
Vehrencamp
SL
.
Principles of animal communication
.
Sunderland
:
Sinauer Associates
;
2011
.
8.
Brzoska
J
,
Walkowiak
W
,
Schneider
H
.
Acoustic communication in the grass frog (Rana t. temporaria L.): calls, auditory thresholds and behavioral responses
.
J Comp Physiol
.
1977
;
118
(
2
):
173
86
.
9.
Buerkle
NP
,
Schrode
KM
,
Bee
MA
.
Assessing stimulus and subject influences on auditory evoked potentials and their relation to peripheral physiology in green treefrogs (Hyla cinerea)
.
Comp Biochem Physiol A Mol Integr Physiol
.
2014
;
178
:
68
81
.
10.
Capranica
RR
,
Moffat
AJM
.
Selectivity of the peripheral auditory system of spadefoot toads (Scaphiopus couchi) for sounds of biological significance
.
J Comp Physiol
.
1975
;
100
(
3
):
231
49
.
11.
Chen
Z
,
Wiens
JJ
.
The origins of acoustic communication in vertebrates
.
Nat Commun
.
2020 Dec 17
;
11
(
1
):
369
.
12.
Chung
SH
,
Pettigrew
AG
,
Anson
M
.
Hearing in the frog: dynamics of the middle ear
.
Proc R Soc B Biol Sci
.
1981
;
212
(
1189
):
459
85
.
13.
Corfield
JR
,
Long
B
,
Krilow
JM
,
Wylie
DR
,
Iwaniuk
AN
.
A unique cellular scaling rule in the avian auditory system
.
Brain Struct Funct
.
2016 Jun
;
221
(
5
):
2675
93
.
14.
Eberhard
WG
,
Wcislo
WT
.
Grade changes in brain-body allometry. Morphological and behavioural correlates of brain size in miniature spiders, insects and other invertebrates
. In:
Casas
J
, editor.
Advances in insect physiology
. 1st ed.
Amsterdam
:
Elsevier
;
2011
. p.
155
214
.
15.
Felsenstein
J
.
Phylogenies and the comparative method
.
Am Nat
.
1985 Jan
;
125
(
1
):
1
15
.
16.
Feng
AS
,
Narins
PM
,
Xu
CH
,
Lin
WY
,
Yu
ZL
,
Qiu
Q
,
.
Ultrasonic communication in frogs
.
Nature
.
2006 Mar
;
440
(
7082
):
333
6
.
17.
Fletcher
NH
.
A simple frequency-scaling rule for animal communication
.
J Acoust Soc Am
.
2004 May
;
115
(
5
):
2334
8
.
18.
Fox
JH
.
Morphological correlates of auditory sensitivity in anuran amphibians
.
Brain Behav Evol
.
1995
;
45
(
6
):
327
38
.
19.
Freckleton
RP
,
Harvey
PH
,
Pagel
M
.
Phylogenetic analysis and comparative data: a test and review of evidence
.
Am Nat
.
2002 Dec
;
160
(
6
):
712
26
.
20.
Frishkopf
LS
,
Capranica
RR
,
Goldstein
MH
.
Neural coding in the bullfrog’s auditory system a teleological approach
.
Proc IEEE
.
1968
;
56
(
6
):
969
80
.
21.
Frishkopf
LS
,
Goldstein
MH
.
Responses to acoustic stimuli from single units in the eighth nerve of the bullfrog
.
J Acoust Soc Am
.
1963
;
35
(
8
):
1219
28
.
22.
Fuzessery
ZM
,
Feng
AS
.
Frequency selectivity in the anuran auditory midbrain: single unit responses to single and multiple tone stimulation
.
J Comp Physiol
.
1982
;
146
(
4
):
471
84
.
23.
Gall
MD
,
Bee
MA
,
Baugh
AT
.
The difference a day makes: breeding remodels hearing, hormones and behavior in female Cope’s gray treefrogs (Hyla chrysoscelis)
.
Horm Behav
.
2019 Feb
;
108
:
62
72
.
24.
Gall
MD
,
Wilczynski
W
.
Hearing conspecific vocal signals alters peripheral auditory sensitivity
.
Proc Biol Sci
.
2015
;
282
(
1808
):
20150749
.
25.
Gerhardt
HC
.
Significance of two frequency bands in long distance vocal communication in the green treefrog
.
Nature
.
1976
;
261
(
5562
):
692
4
.
26.
Gerhardt
HC
.
Mating call recognition in the green treefrog (Hyla cinerea): importance of two frequency bands as a function of sound pressure level
.
J Comp Physiol
.
1981
;
144
(
1
):
9
16
.
27.
Gerhardt
HC
.
The evolution of vocalization in frogs and toads
.
Annu Rev Ecol Syst
.
1994
;
25
(
1
):
293
324
.
28.
Gerhardt
HC
,
Schwartz
JJ
.
Auditory tuning and frequency preferences in anurans
. In:
Ryan
MJ
, editor.
Anuran communication
.
Washington DC
:
Smithsonian Institution Press
;
2001
. p.
73
85
.
29.
Gillooly
JF
,
Ophir
AG
.
The energetic basis of acoustic communication
.
Proc Biol Sci
.
2010
;
277
(
1686
):
1325
31
.
30.
Gingras
B
,
Boeckle
M
,
Herbst
CT
,
Fitch
WT
.
Call acoustics reflect body size across four clades of anurans
.
J Zool
.
2013
;
289
(
2
):
143
50
.
31.
Goller
F
,
Riede
T
.
Integrative physiology of fundamental frequency control in birds
.
J Physiol Paris
.
2013 Jun
;
107
(
3
):
230
42
.
32.
Gould
S
.
Ontogeny and phylogeny
.
Cambridge
:
Harvard University Press
;
1977
.
33.
Goutte
S
,
Mason
MJ
,
Christensen-Dalsgaard
J
,
Montealegre
ZF
,
Chivers
BD
,
Sarria
SFA
,
.
Evidence of auditory insensitivity to vocalization frequencies in two frogs
.
Sci Rep
.
2017
;
7
(
1
):
12121
.
34.
Heffner
HE
.
Hearing in large and small dogs: absolute thresholds and size of the tympanic membrane
.
Behav Neurosci
.
1983
;
97
(
2
):
310
8
.
35.
Heffner
R
,
Heffner
H
.
Hearing in the elephant (Elephas maximus)
.
Science
.
1980 May 2
;
208
(
4443
):
518
20
.
36.
Heyer
WR
,
de Carvalho
CM
.
Calls and calling behavior of the frog Leptodactylus natalensis (Amphibia: Anura: Leptodactylidae)
.
Proc Biol Soc Washingt
.
2000
;
113
(
1
):
284
90
.
37.
Hillery
CM
.
Seasonality of two midbrain auditory responses in the treefrog, Hyla chrysoscelis
.
Copeia
.
1984
;
1984
(
4
):
844
.
38.
Huang
GT
,
Rosowski
JJ
,
Peake
WT
.
Relating middle-ear acoustic performance to body size in the cat family: measurements and models
.
J Comp Physiol A
.
2000 May 29
;
186
(
5
):
447
65
.
39.
Hubl
L
,
Schneider
H
.
Temperature and auditory thresholds: bioacoustic studies of the frogs Rana r. ridibunda, Hyla a. arborea and Hyla a. savignyi (Anura, amphibia)
.
J Comp Physiol A
.
1979
;
130
(
1
):
17
27
.
40.
Huxley
J
.
Problems of relative growth
.
London
:
Methuen and Co.
;
1932
.
41.
Jetz
W
,
Pyron
RA
.
The interplay of past diversification and evolutionary isolation with present imperilment across the amphibian tree of life
.
Nat Ecol Evol
.
2018 May
;
2
(
5
):
850
8
.
42.
Katbamna
B
,
Brown
JA
,
Collard
M
,
Ide
CF
.
Auditory brainstem responses to airborne sounds in the aquatic frog Xenopus laevis: correlation with middle ear characteristics
.
J Comp Physiol A Neuroethol Sens Neural Behav Physiol
.
2006
;
192
(
4
):
381
7
.
43.
Lauridsen
TB
,
Brandt
C
,
Christensen-Dalsgaard
J
.
Three auditory brainstem response (ABR) methods tested and compared in two anuran species
.
J Exp Biol
.
2020 Jan 1
;
224
(
Pt 2
):
jeb237313
.
44.
Lee
N
,
Christensen-Dalsgaard
J
,
White
LA
,
Schrode
KM
,
Bee
MA
.
Lung mediated auditory contrast enhancement improves the signal-to-noise ratio for communication in frogs
.
Curr Biol
.
2021
;
31
(
7
):
1488
98.e4
.
45.
Lee
N
,
Ward
JL
,
Vélez
A
,
Micheyl
C
,
Bee
MA
.
Frogs exploit statistical regularities in noisy acoustic scenes to solve cocktail-party-like problems
.
Curr Biol
.
2017 Mar
;
27
(
5
):
743
50
.
46.
Loftus-Hills
J
.
Comparative aspects of auditory function in Australian anurans
.
Aust J Zool
.
1973
;
21
(
3
):
353
.
47.
Loftus-Hills
JJ
,
Johnstone
BM
.
Auditory function, communication, and the brain-evoked response in anuran amphibians
.
J Acoust Soc Am
.
1970
;
47
(
4
):
1131
8
.
48.
Lombard
RE
,
Straughan
IR
.
Functional aspects of anuran middle ear structures
.
J Exp Biol
.
1974
;
61
(
1
):
71
93
.
49.
Mai
CL
,
Liao
WB
.
Brain size evolution in anurans: a review
.
Animal Biol
.
2019
;
69
(
3
):
265
79
.
50.
Mason
MJ
.
Pathways for sound transmission to the inner ear in amphibians
.
Hear Sound Commun Amphib
.
2006
:
147
83
.
51.
McClelland
BE
,
Wilczynski
W
,
Rand
AS
.
Sexual dimorphism and species differences in the neurophysiology and morphology of the acoustic communication system of two neotropical hylids
.
J Comp Physiol A
.
1997
;
180
(
5
):
451
62
.
52.
Megela-Simmons
A
,
Moss
CF
,
Daniel
KM
.
Behavioral audiograms of the bullfrog (Rana catesbeiana) and the green tree frog (Hyla cinerea)
.
J Acoust Soc Am
.
1985
;
78
(
4
):
1236
44
.
53.
Miranda
JA
,
Wilczynski
W
.
Female reproductive state influences the auditory midbrain response
.
J Comp Physiol A Neuroethol Sens Neural Behav Physiol
.
2009a
;
195
(
4
):
341
9
.
54.
Miranda
JA
,
Wilczynski
W
.
Sex differences and androgen influences on midbrain auditory thresholds in the green treefrog, Hyla cinerea
.
Hear Res
.
2009b
;
252
(
1–2
):
79
88
.
55.
Montgomery
SH
,
Mundy
NI
,
Barton
RA
.
Brain evolution and development: adaptation, allometry and constraint
.
Proc R Soc B Biol Sci
.
2016
;
283
(
1838
).
56.
Mundry
R
.
Statistical issues and assumptions of phylogenetic generalized least squares. Modern phylogenetic comparative methods and their application in evolutionary biology
.
Berlin
:
Springer
;
2014
. p.
131
53
.
57.
Orme
CDL
,
Freckleton
RP
,
Thomas
GH
,
Petzoldt
T
,
Fritz
SA
.
The caper package: comparative analyses of phylogenetics and evolution in R
.
2012
. Available from: http://caper.r-forge.r-project.org.
58.
Penna
M
,
Capranica
RR
,
Somers
J
.
Hormone-induced vocal behavior and midbrain auditory sensitivity in the green treefrog, Hyla cinerea
.
J Comp Physiol A
.
1992 Jan
;
170
(
1
):
73
82
.
59.
Penna
M
,
Palazzi
C
,
Paolinelli
P
,
Solís
R
.
Midbrain auditory sensitivity in toads of the genus Bufo (Amphibia – Bufonidae) with different vocal repertoires
.
J Comp Physiol A
.
1990 Nov
;
167
(
5
):
673
81
.
60.
Penna
M
,
Plaza
A
,
Moreno-Gómez
FN
.
Severe constraints for sound communication in a frog from the South American temperate forest
.
J Comp Physiol A Neuroethol Sens Neural Behav Physiol
.
2013
;
199
(
8
):
723
33
.
61.
Penna
M
,
Velásquez
N
,
Solís
R
.
Correspondence between evoked vocal responses and auditory thresholds in Pleurodema thaul (Amphibia; Leptodactylidae)
.
J Comp Physiol A Neuroethol Sens Neural Behav Physiol
.
2008
;
194
(
4
):
361
71
.
62.
Penna
M
,
Velásquez
NA
,
Bosch
J
.
Dissimilarities in auditory tuning in midwife toads of the genus Alytes (Amphibia: Anura)
.
Biol J Linn Soc
.
2015
;
116
(
1
):
41
51
.
63.
Purgue
AP
.
Tympanic sound radiation in the bullfrog Rana catesbeiana
.
J Comp Physiol A
.
1997 Oct 20
;
181
(
5
):
438
45
.
64.
Richards
CL
.
Has the evolution of complexity in the amphibian papilla influenced anuran speciation rates
.
J Evol Biol
.
2006
;
19
(
4
):
1222
30
.
65.
Riede
T
,
Goller
F
.
Morphological basis for the evolution of acoustic diversity in oscine songbirds
.
Proc Biol Sci
.
2014 Feb 5
;
281
(
1779
):
20132306
.
66.
Ryan
MJ
.
Neuroanatomy influences speciation rates among anurans
.
Proc Natl Acad Sci U S A
.
1986 Mar 1
;
83
(
5
):
1379
82
.
67.
Ryan
MJ
,
Fox
JH
,
Wilczynski
W
,
Rand
AS
.
Sexual selection for sensory exploitation in the frog Physalaemus pustulosus
.
Nature
.
1990 Jan
;
343
(
6253
):
66
7
.
68.
Ryan
MJ
,
Rand
AS
.
The sensory basis of sexual selection for complex calls in the túngara frog, Physalaemus pustulosus (sexual selection for sensory exploitation)
.
Evolution
.
1990
;
44
(
2
):
305
.
69.
Schmidt-Nielsen
K
.
Scaling: why is animal size so important?
Cambridge
:
Cambridge University Press
;
1984
.
70.
Schrode
KM
,
Buerkle
NP
,
Brittan-Powell
EF
,
Bee
MA
.
Auditory brainstem responses in Cope’s gray treefrog (Hyla chrysoscelis): effects of frequency, level, sex and size
.
J Comp Physiol A
.
2014 Mar 18
;
200
(
3
):
221
38
.
71.
Simmons
DD
,
Meenderink
SWF
,
Vassilakis
PN
.
Anatomy, physiology, and function of auditory end-organs in the frog inner ear. Hearing and sound communication in amphibians
.
New York
:
Springer
;
2006
. p.
184
220
.
72.
Smotherman
MS
,
Narins
PM
.
Hair cells, hearing and hopping: a field guide to hair cell physiology in the frog
.
J Exp Biol
.
2000 Aug 1
;
203
(
15
):
2237
46
.
73.
Sun
X
,
Zhao
L
,
Chen
Q
,
Wang
J
,
Cui
J
.
Auditory sensitivity changes with diurnal temperature variation in little torrent frogs (Amolops torrentis)
.
Bioacoustics
.
2020
;
29
(
6
):
684
96
.
74.
Taylor
RC
,
Akre
KA
,
Wilczynski
W
,
Ryan
MJ
.
Behavioral and neural auditory thresholds in a frog
.
Curr Zool
.
2019
;
65
(
3
):
333
341
.
75.
Tonini
JFR
,
Provete
DB
,
Maciel
NM
,
Morais
AR
,
Goutte
S
,
Toledo
LF
,
.
Allometric escape from acoustic constraints is rare for frog calls
.
Ecol Evol
.
2020
;
10
(
8
):
3686
95
.
76.
Vélez
A
,
Höbel
G
,
Gordon
NM
,
Bee
MA
.
Dip listening or modulation masking? Call recognition by green treefrogs (Hyla cinerea) in temporally fluctuating noise
.
J Comp Physiol A Neuroethol Sensory Neural Behav Physiol
.
2012
;
198
(
12
):
891
904
.
77.
Wake
DB
,
Vredenburg
VT
.
Are we in the midst of the sixth mass extinction? A view from the world of amphibians
.
Proc Natl Acad Sci
.
2008
;
105
(
Suppl 1
):
11466
11473
.
78.
Walkowiak
W
.
The coding of auditory signals in the torus semicircularis of the fire-bellied toad and the grass frog: responses to simple stimuli and to conspecific calls
.
J Comp Physiol
.
1980
;
138
(
2
):
131
48
.
79.
Wallschläger
D
.
Correlation of song frequency and body weight in passerine birds
.
Experientia
.
1980 Apr 1
;
36
(
4
):
412
.
80.
Wells
KD
,
Schwartz
JJ
.
The behavioral ecology of anuran communication
.
Hear Sound Commun Amphib
.
2006
:
44
86
.
81.
Wever
EG
.
The amphibian ear
.
Princeton
:
Princeton University Press
;
1985
.
82.
Wilczynski
W
,
Capranica
RR
.
The auditory system of anuran amphibians
.
Prog Neurobiol
.
1984 Jan
;
22
(
1
):
1
38
.
83.
Wilczynski
W
,
Keddy-Hector
AC
,
Ryan
MJ
.
Call patterns and basilar papilla tuning in cricket frogs. I. differences among populations and between sexes
.
Brain Behav Evol
.
1992
;
39
(
4
):
229
37
.
84.
Wilczynski
W
,
Zakon
HH
,
Brenowitz
EA
.
Acoustic communication in spring peepers
.
J Comp Physiol
.
1984
;
155
(
5
):
577
84
.
85.
Womack
MC
,
Bell
RC
.
Two-hundred million years of anuran body-size evolution in relation to geography, ecology and life history
.
J Evol Biol
.
2020
;
33
(
10
):
1417
32
.
86.
Womack
MC
,
Christensen-Dalsgaard
J
,
Coloma
LA
,
Hoke
KL
.
Sensitive high frequency hearing in earless and partially eared harlequin frogs (Atelopus)
.
J Exp Biol
.
2018 Jan 1
;
221
(
Pt 10
):
jeb169664
.
87.
Yang
Y
,
Zhu
B
,
Wang
J
,
Brauth
SE
,
Tang
Y
,
Cui
J
.
A test of the matched filter hypothesis in two sympatric frogs, Chiromantis doriae and Feihyla vittata
.
Bioacoustics
.
2019
;
28
(
5
):
488
502
.
88.
Yu
ZL
,
Qiu
Q
,
Xu
ZM
,
Shen
JX
.
Auditory response characteristics of the piebald odorous frog and their implications
.
J Comp Physiol A Neuroethol Sens Neural Behav Physiol
.
2006
;
192
(
8
):
801
6
.
89.
Zelick
R
,
Narins
PM
.
Temporary threshold shift, adaptation, and recovery characteristics of frog auditory nerve fibers
.
Hear Res
.
1985
;
17
(
2
):
161
76
.
90.
Zhang
D
,
Cui
J
,
Tang
Y
.
Plasticity of peripheral auditory frequency sensitivity in Emei music frog
.
PLoS One
.
2012
;
7
(
9
):
e45792
.
You do not currently have access to this content.