Abstract
Reactive oxygen species (ROS) are elevated in humans with hypertension many of which develop end-stage renal disease (ESRD), and antioxidant capacity is decreased. About one-half of essential hypertensives have a salt-sensitive type of hypertension, and the amount of renal damage that occurs in salt-sensitive hypertensives greatly exceeds that of non-salt-sensitive hypertensives. Antioxidant therapy can improve cardiovascular outcomes in humans but only if sufficient doses are used. Salt-sensitive hypertensive animal models, especially Dahl salt-sensitive rats, have been used to investigate the relationship between hypertension, ROS and end-stage renal damage. In experimental salt-sensitive hypertension, ROS increase and significant renal damage occur. In the Dahl salt-sensitive (S) rat on high Na for 3 weeks, renal damage is mild, renal levels of superoxide dismutase are decreased, and treatment with Tempol reduces arterial pressure. In the Dahl S rat on high Na for 5 weeks, renal damage is severe, GFR and renal plasma flow are decreased, and renal superoxide production is high. Treatment with vitamins C and E decreases renal superoxide production and renal damage and prevents the decrease in renal hemodynamics. Antioxidant treatment reduces arterial pressure, aortic superoxide production and renal inflammation in DOCA-salt rats, and decreases blood pressure and aortic superoxide release and increases bioactive nitric oxide in SHR stroke-prone rats. In conclusion, in both human and experimental salt-sensitive hypertension, superoxide production and renal damage are increased, antioxidant capacity is decreased, and antioxidant therapy can be helpful.
Introduction
The kidney is one of the major end organ targets of hypertension. The latest report from the US and Europe indicates that the prevalence of end-stage renal disease (ESRD) secondary to hypertension continues to multiply rapidly [1]. About one-half of essential hypertensives have a salt-sensitive type of hypertension, and both salt-sensitive hypertensive patient and salt-sensitive animal models have shown that they are much more susceptible to renal damage than the non-salt-sensitive models of hypertension. However, the mechanisms of hypertension and the associated renal damage are not well known. One possible mechanism that is associated with hypertension and renal damage is oxidative stress. In this review, we present evidence from studies in humans and experimental animals that shows that oxidative stress is an important phenomenon that contributes to hypertension and links hypertension with ESRD.
There is growing evidence that oxidative stress plays a major role in hypertension. Several studies have shown that induced oxidative stress can cause hypertension, oxidative stress increases in experimental hypertension, renal oxidative stress can cause renal damage, and reversal of oxidative stress with antioxidants decreases blood pressure. Studies supporting these findings will be presented in subsequent sections.
Induction of Oxidative Stress Causes Hypertension
Studies in which oxidative stress has been experimentally induced have caused increases in oxidative stress and hypertension. These results provide strong evidence for either an initiating or a sustaining role of ROS in hypertension.
Several studies have clearly shown that induction of oxidative stress with lead administration initiates hypertension. Lead enhanced both O2·– and hydroxyl radical production in cultured endothelial cells and intact animals [2,3,4]. Rats with increased lead in their drinking water experience an increase in ROS and nitrosylation of tyrosine in their blood vessels, and blood pressure increased [5]. Treatment with antioxidants lowered blood pressure and increased bioavailable nitric oxide [5].
Other evidence that showed that oxidative stress can cause hypertension has been provided in studies in which glutathione synthase was inhibited with buthionine sulfoximine (BSO) in the drinking water of rats. Arterial pressure and ROS increased as well as nitrotyrosine deposits in major organs, and nitric oxide (NO) metabolites in the urine decreased. When antioxidants were administered along with the BSO, the blood pressure increase was attenuated, tissue nitrotyrosine decreased, and NO in the urine increased [6, 7]. Collectively, these data show that BSO-induced hypertension is mediated by increased ROS.
Transgenic rats also provide further evidence that induced oxidative stress can cause hypertension. In mice, deletion of the extracellular superoxide dismutase (SOD) gene caused increased oxidative stress and increased arterial pressure during low dose angiotensin II infusion [8]. On the other hand, transfer of the human extracellular SOD gene into SHR decreased their blood pressure [9]. Fibulin-5 binds extracellular SOD to vascular tissue, and deletion of the fibulin-5 gene raises the blood pressure of mice [10, 11]. Therefore, changes in the key antioxidant SOD by gene manipulation change oxidative stress and blood pressure.
Studies in normotensive rats have shown that a high Na diet can significantly increase oxidative stress in spite of a lack of increase in arterial pressure. Arteriolar and venular O2·– production increased in Sprague-Dawley rats fed a high Na diet for 4–5 weeks [12]. Tempol + catalase or SOD + catalase decreased the O2·– production [12]. In these studies endothelium-dependent vasodilation was attenuated, and the mechanism by which O2·– causes endothelium dysfunction involves an inactivation of NO [13]. In normotensive Dahl R rats, a 3-week period of high Na intake caused an increase in urinary F2-isoprostane excretion [14]. However, neither renal medullary nor renal cortical O2·– production increased in these high Na Dahl R rats suggesting that an extrarenal source of O2·– production may be present.
One might wonder why the increases in O2·– production in the above studies on rats with a high Na diet did not increase arterial pressure, since many studies have indicated that increased O2·– production will cause hypertension. A recent study may give us the answer. In Sprague-Dawley rats that received a high Na diet for 8 weeks, which is much longer than the above-mentioned studies, the arterial pressure increased significantly, and urinary albumin excretion and renal inflammation increased [15]. It appears that hypertension develops slowly when Na intake is increased in normotensive rats, and the blood pressure elevations are paralleled by increases in ROS and renal damage. Therefore, long-term exposure to a high Na diet causes slow but progressive increases in oxidative stress, renal inflammation, and renal damage and arterial pressure.
Oxidative Stress in Experimental Hypertension
Further evidence that oxidative stress is plays a role in hypertension is provided by experimental hypertension studies. Increased oxidative stress has been found in the SHR, the stroke-prone SHR, DOCA-salt hypertension and the Dahl salt-sensitive rat [14,16,17,18,19,20]. Different antioxidants in these studies reduced the elevated blood pressure indicating a role of oxidative stress in the etiology of the hypertension. However, in these models it is difficult to determine whether the oxidative stress is due to the high pressure or to other humoral, hormonal or genetic factors. A recent study has been helpful in dissecting out the effects of pressure and other factors on oxidative stress [21]. Rats received a suprarenal aortic band producing a coarctation and hypertension resulted.
Therefore, the area above the coarctation was hypertensive and the area below was normotensive. ROS-mediated NO inactivation occurred in the high pressure area but not in the normotensive area, and NADPH oxidase increased in the hypertensive area of the aorta which may be a source of the increased O2·– production [22]. Therefore, studies reviewed thus far in this manuscript have shown that oxidative stress can cause hypertension, but also that hypertension can cause increased oxidative stress.
Renal Oxidative Stress Can Cause Hypertension and Renal Damage
Release of the superoxide anion in the kidney can have several deleterious effects. First, NO can be inactivated by O2·–. Since NO has several important renal actions such as prevention of tubular Na reabsorption and blunting of tubular glomerular feedback [23], inactivation of NO can result in excess Na reabsorption and enhanced TGF feedback and thus hypertension [24,25,26]. Inactivation of NO with O2·– forms peroxynitrite [27] which can nitrosylate tyrosine residues and thus cause tissue damage including renal damage.
In hypertensive models ROS production in the kidney has been evidenced by the presence of renal nitrotyrosine, considered to be a footprint of peroxynitrite. Those models with nitrotyrosine immunoreactivity are lead-induced hypertension [5], coarctation of the aorta [21], and the SHR [28]. In the Dahl salt-sensitive rat O2·– production from the renal cortical and medullary homogenates increases during high Na intake [14, 29], and Tempol administration lowers the O2·– production. Direct measurements of H2O2 from the renal interstitium have been made in rats with renal medullary SOD inhibition. These rats become hypertensive and Tempol + catalase infusion will prevent the increases in blood pressure [30]. This group also showed that direct infusion of H2O2 into the renal medullary interstitium causes hypertension. The Tempol administration in these rats increased the formation of H2O2, and the catalase metabolized the H2O2.
Other evidence for renal ROS during hypertension includes excretion of lipid peroxidation products. F2-isoprostane and malondialdehyde excretion increases in the SHR [16], in Dahl salt-sensitive hypertension [14, 31], in angiotensin II infusion [32], and in DOCA-salt hypertension [18, 19].
The mechanism by which renal ROS could cause hypertension has been studied by several investigators. During acute infusion of Tempol in the SHR, arterial pressure and renal vascular resistance decreased [33]. This response was blocked by NO synthase inhibition but not by norepinephrine. This suggests that the inactivation of NO with O2·– may play an important role in this hypertension by increasing renal vascular resistance.
Inactivation of NO with O2·– in the thick ascending limb of Henle enhances Na reabsorption [34]. Studies have also shown that O2·– causes direct vasoconstriction in the renal cortical and medullary circulation [35, 36] and increases intracellular calcium in vascular smooth muscle and endothelial cells [37]. Isoprostanes also constrict the preglomerular vasculature [38]. Therefore, renal ROS not only cause renal vasoconstriction and Na retention but also renal damage as is described below.
Renal Damage in Salt-Sensitive Hypertension
During increases in blood pressure the experimental models of salt-insensitive hypertension that experience an increase in preglomerular resistance, such as the SHR, receive little renal damage. Yet the salt-sensitive hypertensive models experience significant and progressive renal damage. The likely difference is that in the salt-insensitive models, the increase in preglomerular resistance protects the glomerulus and distal vasculature from high pressures. Compared to the salt-insensitive models such as the SHR, the salt-sensitive models do not experience the increased preglomerular resistance which causes exposure of the glomerulus and distal vasculature to high pressures. These high intrarenal pressures may lead to significant oxidative stress, inflammation and renal damage.
Several studies have shown that a Dahl salt-sensitive (S) rat exposed to a high Na diet will experience severe renal damage. After 2–5 weeks on high Na intake the Dahl S rats exhibit signs of significant renal damage associated with increased oxidative stress [14, 20, 29, 31]. Early signs of renal damage include increases in urinary protein excretion [14, 20]. Later, GFR and renal plasma flow, measured in conscious rats, decrease, and marked glomerular and vascular necrosis occur, and tubulo-interstitial damage is significant [29]. Left untreated these renal changes will rapidly progress to acute renal failure.
DOCA-salt rats also experience increased oxidative stress and show signs of renal inflammation. When DOCA-salt rats were treated with the antioxidant and NF-ĸB antagonist, pyrrolidinedithiocarbamate (PDTC) or the SOD mimetic, Tempol, significant decreases occurred in systolic blood pressure, aortic O2·–E accumulation, renal monocyte/macrophage infiltration, and NF-ĸB binding activity compared with untreated DOCA rats [19]. These results support an important role for oxidative stress in DOCA-salt hypertension, and the O2·– release in DOCA-salt rats is associated with a renal inflammatory response.
Antioxidants Attenuate Renal Damage and Decrements in Renal Function in Salt-Sensitive Hypertension
In the Dahl S rat a 3-week high Na diet decreases renal Cu/Zn SOD and Mn SOD, which causes an increase in renal O2·– production (SOD). The SOD mimetic, Tempol, reduces renal O2·– production, renal damage and arterial pressure. However, renal damage in the Dahl S rat is much more severe after 5 weeks of a high Na diet, and the kidneys appear like those from patients with malignant hypertension. The renal damage that occurs in S rats on high Na includes renal interstitial damage, glomerular and arterial necrosis with thrombosed arteries and arterioles [29]. Treatment of rats with the antioxidants, vitamin C and E markedly reduced the renal damage. In addition, vitamins C and E prevented the pronounced decreases in GFR and renal plasma flow that occur in Dahl S rats on high Na for 5 weeks [29].
In Dahl S rats on high Na for 5 weeks, significant renal morphological damage occurred, and urinary protein excretion increased. Both renal structural damage and urinary protein excretion decreased when the high Na S rats were treated with vitamins C and E [29]. In the past, many investigators believed that the renal damage in hypertension was directly due to exposure of the kidney to high pressures. However, oxidative stress markedly increased in high Na Dahl S rats, and scavenging of the free radicals with vitamins C and E reduced the renal damage even though mean arterial pressure only decreased 20 mm Hg. In particular, the superoxide release from the renal cortex and medulla in the high Na Dahl rats was significantly decreased in vitamin-treated rats, and this was associated with a reduction in renal damage. These data indicate that renal oxidative stress plays an important role in the hypertension and the associated renal damage in high Na Dahl S rats. However, one cannot preclude the possibility that the decrease in arterial pressure caused a reduction in renal damage.
There are several possible explanations for the GFR and renal plasma flow decreases in Dahl salt-sensitive rats during high Na intake. First, glomerular necrosis and interstitial damage occurred in high Na S rats, and we have also reported that vascular necrosis was present [29]. A decrease in the number of functional nephrons with its associated vasculature could thus occur, and by this means GFR and renal plasma flow would decrease. Second, salt-sensitive hypertension has been associated with an increase in vasoconstrictor release. We have shown that F2-isoprostanes are released in Dahl S rats on high Na intake [14], and these isoprostanes can act as vasoconstrictors [14].
Increased intrarenal angiotensin II has also been reported during a high Na diet [39], and this can also result in renal vasoconstriction. Third, increased renal O2·– release inactivates nitric oxide thus decreasing renal vasodilation which is equivalent to increased vasoconstriction. This would cause decreases in cGMP as has been reported in Dahl S rats on high Na [31].
Other salt-sensitive models have responded favorably to treatment with antioxidants. In DOCA-salt rats, treatment with antioxidants PDTC or Tempol decreased arterial pressure, vascular O2·– production and renal infiltration of immune cells [19]. In the SHRSP, Tempol or vitamins C and E reduced oxidative stress and prevented progression of hypertension [40].
Oxidative Stress in Human End-Stage Renal Disease
In ERSD patients the antioxidant-pro-oxidant balance is shifted toward an increased oxidative stress. Several antioxidant systems have been shown to be deficient in patients with chronic renal insufficiency. Reduced levels of vitamin C are present, in part due to a dietary restriction of fresh fruits and vegetables to avoid hyperkalemia, and vitamin E intracellular levels are low, selenium levels are reduced, and there is a deficiency in the glutathione system [41, 42]. The imbalance in pro- and anti-oxidant capacities in these patients results in excess production of ROS in the blood [43], and neutrophils in uremic patients produce more ROS when stimulated.
The oxidant stress in dialysis patients causes increases in malondialdehyde, oxidized LDL, and increases in antibodies against oxidized LDL [44]. Oxidative stress in renal failure has been associated with hypertension [45, 46] endothelial dysfunction [47], decreased erythrocyte lifespan [48,49,50,51], and atherosclerosis and inflammation [52].
Oxidative Stress in Human Hypertension
Hypertension is a significant and independent risk factor for renal damage [53], especially in patients with salt-sensitive hypertension, and there is a strong association between hypertension and oxidative stress. Several studies have shown that humans with essential hypertension have a decreased antioxidant capacity [54,55,56,57] and release increased amounts of ROS [58, 59]. SOD activity in erythrocytes is decreased in essential hypertensive patients [57, 60] and vitamin E levels are also reduced [60]. O2·– and H2O2 released by leukocytes and plasma concentrations of lipid peroxides increased in hypertensive patients whose blood pressure was not controlled [57]. Antihypertensive therapy in these patients decreased free radical production and lipid peroxides to normal [59].
More than one-half of essential hypertensive patients have a salt-sensitive hypertension [61] with abnormal renal sodium handling [62], and this is accompanied by progressive renal damage [63]. In a recent study, 73% of black hypertensives were salt sensitive compared to 56% of white hypertensives, and renal damage occurred twice as much in the black group. These data indicate that an increase in oxidative stress could be a contributory mechanism in human salt-sensitive hypertension, and oxidative stress may play an important role in the renal damage associated with salt-sensitive hypertension.
Antioxidant Therapy in Humans
Because of the positive results of vitamin C or E treatment in animal experimental studies, several clinical trials have been performed to determine if vitamin treatment can improve cardiovascular disease. Most clinical studies on vitamin E used doses equal to or less than 400 IU/day, and no significant reduction in cardiovascular risk has been found [64, 65]. However, when 800 IU/day of vitamin E was used in the CHAOS [66] and SPACE [67] trials, significant decreases in cardiovascular risk occurred. Several studies have shown that there is an inverse relationship between serum vitamin C and blood pressure in humans. Although variable results have been found, some studies have shown that treatment of hypertensive patients with vitamin C lowers blood pressure [68].
The reason why vitamins C and E improve cardiovascular function in experimental studies and in some human studies but not in others has several possible causes. First, the doses of vitamins C and E used in clinical studies may be too low. In a recent 16-week study in hypercholesterolemic patients, 400 IU/day of vitamin E did not decrease serum levels of F2-isoprostanes, but doses of vitamin E of 800–3,200 IU/day caused significant reductions in F2-isoprostane levels [69]. A second reason why vitamin E was ineffective in some clinical studies is that vitamin E can become a free radical in the body [70], but vitamin C can convert the pro-oxidant vitamin E radical back to vitamin E [70].
In most clinical studies either vitamin C or E is used alone, but the combination may be effective and attack free radicals on lipid membranes and in the cytosol. A third reason why vitamin therapy is ineffective in clinical studies is that the patients had preexisting conditions when they entered the studies [64,65,66,67]. In studies in our laboratory [29], the combination of vitamins C and E successfully decreased renal oxidative stress, prevented decreases in renal hemodynamics and decreased arterial pressure and renal damage in Dahl S rats on high Na for 5 weeks.
In patients with chronic renal insufficiency, oral vitamin E supplements reduced the tendency for LDL to be oxidized, which is a key step in the development of atherosclerosis [71]. Vitamin E prevented the oxidative stress during anemia therapy or improved erythropoietin responsiveness, which is often impaired by oxidative stress.
Dialysis membranes often trigger an oxidative stress response, and vitamin E-modified dialysis membranes reduced oxidative stress in one study [72].
Conclusions
ROS, especially O2·–, is elevated in human hypertension and in patients with ESRD, and their antioxidant capacity is decreased. Salt-sensitive hypertensives have progressive decreases in renal function. In experimental salt-sensitive hypertension, renal O2·– production in Dahl S rats cause progressive increases in renal damage and decreases in renal hemodynamics. Several antioxidant regimens such as vitamins C and E and Tempol decrease renal tissue O2·– production, prevent renal damage, increase renal hemodynamics and decrease blood pressure. These studies provide evidence supporting a hypothesis that ROS play an important role in the progression of salt-sensitive hypertension and the accompanying end-stage renal damage.
Acknowledgements
This work was supported by NIH grant Hl-51971 from the National Heart, Lung and Blood Institute.